5 ms·
Don't get your hopes up with this kind of approach. The gotcha is right there in the Abstract: "solid carbon and gallium oxide are the final reaction products
by jiggawatts 5y ago
Don't get your hopes up with this kind of approach.
The gotcha is right there in the Abstract: "solid carbon and gallium oxide are the final reaction products of this process."
This is the thermodynamic equivalent of rearranging the deckchairs on the Titanic. It achieves literally nothing except for shifting the oxygens around. They're still around, still bonded, but even harder. That's what this process doing -- reducing the carbon using a liquid metal. Reducing the gallium oxide back to the metal takes even more energy than was released by burning the C to CO2 in the first place! If you have an energy source that exceeds the world total carbon usage... then you don't need to burn carbon any more![1]
At best, this could be used to convert some magical future energy source like unlimited fusion power into pure carbon, eliminating the need for coal mining. But that's it.
This -- and any approach like this -- can never be practically used to counter the effects of CO2.
The finance equivalent would be: "We found this new way of producing $100 that only requires $110 in expenses!"
Actually not $110 at all. A sibling comment mentioned that "Gallium is cheap (~$300/kg)".
For comparison, coal is on the order of $150/ton. Not kilograms. Tons. Literally 2,000x cheaper than Gallium per unit weight!
So this paper proposes reducing $100 of carbon by using $200,000 of gallium.
Sure, you have gallium oxide left behind that can be recycled for a bit less than $300/kg, but certainly not for $150/ton!
[1] The few direct uses such as using coke to produce iron from its ore can be replaced by hydrogen gas. Similarly, groups are working on processes for iron similar to the one used for aluminium that requires only electricity as the input.
- nrdgrrrl 5y ago
- whiddershins 5y agoI’m genuinely having trouble following what you’re saying. Can you simplify. Too much co2 in the atmosphere is assumed to be a bad thing. Someone says they can sequester co2 from the atmosphere at a certain energy cost. Is your point that this energy cost is unrealizable?
- senectus1 5y agoThis solution isn't about pulling it from the atmosphere.. its about pulling it from a clean direct source.
- jiggawatts 5y agoNone of this matters. This is literally[1] burning $300,000 to save $100. No matter how well you optimise that $300K, it will never ever EVER be less than $100. It can't possibly be, that would break the laws of physics and you'd have essentially a perpetual motion (free energy) machine. If you have 'x' units of carbon (coal), which you burn to make 'e(x)' units of energy and some CO2, turning the resulting CO2 back into 'x' units of carbon will always take more than 'e(x)' units of energy. There is no magical future science that can enable this. It's a fundamental law of thermodynamics! If it were possible, then you could turn 'x' units of carbon back into 'x' units of carbon PLUS have some free energy left over by running the above in a loop. That's absurd. That's literally a perpetual motion machine. You could start with one ton of carbon and never need more to make infinite energy. There is an endless series of "science" papers like this published every year, because it gets funding and attention from people that just don't understand that "there ain't no such thing as a free lunch". They're a total waste of time, and have the same logic as trying to power your ceiling lights by using solar cells as your wallpaper and then connecting the lights to the wallpaper. Isn't that brilliant!? The photons from the ceiling lights will produce electricity in the solar cells, which in turn will power your lights! Never pay electricity bills ever again! NOTE: There are ways of capturing (not "un-burning"!) carbon dioxide and trapping it for less energy that was released by burning the carbon that went into it. That's fundamentally different, and potentially economically viable. [1] Literally! Not figuratively! This process literally burns expensive gallium metal to produce cheap carbon and burnt gallium (gallium oxide).
- steve76 5y ago
- senectus1 5y agoI dont disagree with you, but it does matter that this POC was done using a concentrated pure source of CO2... If it requires that, then its even more pointless apart from the learnings of course, because such scenarios are super super rare in the real world of industry. and in a marketing/politics point of view there is a LOT of bullshit going around about "Carbon Capture and Storage". This POC is likely to revamp that bullshit all over again.. its worth pointing out that this POC did not even slightly come close to the idea of "pulling carbon from the atmosphere". The cost of doing it is so far down the list of reasons to not get overly excited about it.
- elil17 5y agoCan’t use just reduce the gallium oxide with renewable energy when it is available? So your process looks something like: 1. Emit carbon when there is no wind or sun and capture it with gallium. 2. Reduce the resulting gallium oxide when clean energy is available. That makes this essentially a gallium/CO2 battery. Also, it’s not true that cycles like this necessarily require more energy than is generated from the CO2 source. I can’t speak to this one in particular, but there are carbon capture techniques that use less energy than is generated by the combustion source. That’s because the carbon ends up in an energy state that’s lower than it’s energy state in the fuel source (e.g. solid carbon is higher energy than CO2 gas but lower energy than hydrocarbons) and because carbon isn’t the only molecule oxidizing in the combustion reaction, hydrogen is too.
- denton-scratch 5y ago> Can’t use just reduce the gallium oxide with renewable energy when it is available? Renewable energy is not available. It's needed now, in much greater quantities than are available, to supplant hydrocarbons and coal.
- scotty79 5y agoIt's not needed in peak production periods. Energy price then drops below zero. Real trouble is that as long as this excess energy is useless there's no economic incentives to build more renewables.
- tenuousemphasis 5y agoMine bitcoin with the excess energy. That makes it immediately valuable.
- elil17 5y agoI’m not sure if that’s meant as a joke. Adding more hash rate to the blockchain does not create value for society.
- dataflow 5y ago> If you have an energy source that exceeds the world total carbon usage... then you don't need to burn carbon any more! You would though? Carbon is dense and easy to store and transport in bulk, in your car/plane/etc. Whereas solar/nuclear/etc. aren't.