>> This is a remarkably naive (and charmingly optimistic) view of peer-review. Great way to join a convesation. Well done. I didn't say anything about "the va

>> This is a remarkably naive (and charmingly optimistic) view of peer-review. Great way to join a convesation. Well done. I didn't say anything about "the vast majority of history of academic research". I talked about my experience of peer review of my work. Are you responding to someone else's comment but quoting mine?