2 ms·
> People quote fictional characters for the same reason they quote anything else. The quote is a nice package. Except that similar factual claim is never said
by watwut 5y ago
> People quote fictional characters for the same reason they quote anything else. The quote is a nice package.
Except that similar factual claim is never said outside of those quotes. They are used as truism, argument by authority, but content of it is not actually argued.
> Do you feel like random quotes from a known genius like Einstein are somehow worth more?
I actually rarely see those being used to make specific claims. Those tend to be vague. As argument they would be similarly bad, but they are not used that way.
> Do you feel that quotes from fiction that people do not believe is fiction (scripture) are worth more?
I never ever seen quote from scripture being used as argument in HN.
And yes, someone treating Heinlein as Catholics treat Bible would indeed be disturbing.