5 ms·
It seems pretty specific to me. If Congress writes a law that says Google can't integrate hours of operation into Google Maps, they have to defer to Yelp, that
by jeffbee 5y ago
It seems pretty specific to me. If Congress writes a law that says Google can't integrate hours of operation into Google Maps, they have to defer to Yelp, that harms consumers and only helps Yelp. Viewed through that lens, you can and should think of these bills as Yelp welfare.
If you are a big fan of Yelp I guess that's OK for you, but most of us can see that it's a scam.
- coliveira 5y agoBut yelp is not the only company that can compile hours of operation. However, if Google is able to integrate all that into the same product, there will be no yelp or yelp competitor to talk about.
- avirut 5y agoBut as a consumer it's very nice to have hours of operation, directions, phone numbers, and reviews all in one place that's linked to my search engine. I can see how, if Google's top priority is turning a profit, Google having a product so data-rich and unified that it leaves no room for competitors is bad for consumers in the long term. On the other hand, the most desirable option would be a reliably "benevolent" mega-corp that could be trusted to prioritize the user experience while also horizontally integrating across product segments to create a unified service.
- passivate 5y ago>the most desirable option would be a reliably "benevolent" mega-corp that could be trusted to prioritize the user experience while also horizontally integrating across product segments to create a unified service. Why is that desirable? Its not to me. The most desirable outcome is open data exchange standards that allow data exchange so that ANYONE can build such a service. Google locks-up publicly available data and they subsidize/price dump to offer services at no-cost so other players die out leaving them to manipulate the market as they see fit. Its the worst possible outcome for everyone involved.
- jeffbee 5y agoFrom a consumer perspective the death of Yelp is something to be greatly desired. That's the anti-trust perspective of the USA over the last 40 years.
- echelon 5y agoAnd what happens when Google becomes the operating system for the world and you have to do everything through Google? Competition is incredibly important. Imagine if Microsoft hadn't been anti-trusted and didn't have to unbundle the web, pay Apple for their malfeasance, etc. We wouldn't have iPhone / Android.
- bennysomething 5y agoYou think the reason for Android and iPhone is Microsoft anti trust? Why? The final settlement didn't amount to much https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Corp https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_C.... If anything it proves that we didn't need anti trust action, the market took care of itself. Microsoft stagnated, Steve Jobs returned to Apple and innovated, Google had a great search algorithm and piggy backed their infrastructure on free software (Linux) and then ripped off apples design for phone software.
- betwixthewires 5y agoBut it isn't true, I can see an equally likely scenario where Google has to offer its POI maps data to other search engines, making the overall search experience better, to stay competitive.
- endisneigh 5y agoThat doesn’t make any sense. What precedent is there for this sort of action? Do we really want the government to be micro managing the features of online services?
- betwixthewires 5y agoPrecedent? What about Microsoft being forced not to cripple browsers other than IE in windows? That's the most prominent recent example. Just because it doesn't make sense to you doesn't mean it makes no sense at all.
- endisneigh 5y agoThat's not the same as what the parent said at all. When has the government ever forced one company to offer data to another one?
- ancientsofmumu 5y agoThe Telecommunications Act of 1996 did just that, forcing data interoperability between the carriers. Thus, another key provision of the 1996 Act sets obligations for incumbent carriers and new entrants to interconnect their networks with one another, imposing additional requirements on the incumbents because they might desire to restrict competitive entry by denying such interconnection or by setting terms, conditions, and rates that could undermine the ability of the new entrants to compete. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecommunications_Act_of_1996 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecommunications_Act_of_1996
- 5y ago
- frabcus 5y agoOnly if they don’t innovate. They could create a search marketplace for providing high quality hours of operation services, and let multiple providers compete for it.
- jsnell 5y agoOk. So in your new framework, who would be choosing which provider is used, how are the prices set, and who would be compensating the provider? No end user will agree to pay for this data. But you can't have the payer be different from the decision maker.
- frabcus 5y agoBy "they" I meant Google - instead of embedding just their own services in the SERP. I guess it could be a marketplace made by the industry as a whole or regulated by government. But yes, you’re right this needs thought. Developing good regulations is a skill. It happens all over the world in all industries - we need to encourage it to be done well and to iterate and copy practices that work well.
- KoftaBob 5y ago> If Congress writes a law that says Google can't integrate hours of operation into Google Maps I don't get where Google is even getting that scenario from. Where in the antitrust laws does it specify rules that would result in that?