3 ms·
Is Tesla's definition of autopilot way different than the definition used in aircraft?
by criddell 5y ago
Is Tesla's definition of autopilot way different than the definition used in aircraft?
- avalys 5y agoDoes the ordinary consumer have any idea what an aircraft autopilot actually does?
- gamblor956 5y agoYes. An autopilot in a commercial passenger aircraft is fully capable of controlling the plane after takeoff, landing, and taxiing up to the destination gate. Or in other words, after takeoff, it is fully capable of controlling the plane without any input from the pilot. So, when Tesla advertises their cruise control as "autopilot" they are overstating the abilities of autopilot mode if they put in the fine print that a human actually is responsible for controlling the vehicle and that autopilot is just a glorified cruise control.
- Xylakant 5y agoAircraft autopilots are glorified lane-keeping and assistance devices that steer a course in an environment that is reserved for airplanes, with clear lines of sight, clear slots for the individual vehicles and substantial separation between all vehicles in the lane. The environment is free of pedestrians, cyclists, children, footballs and other participants in traffic. If Tesla wants to subscribe to the definition of “autopilot” with the capabilities profile used in aircraft, it must only be usable in comparative environments - that is: a few hundred feet above ground, for takeoff and landing with instrument assist and with pre-assigned slots and fixed routes.
- criddell 5y agoGreat explanation. Thanks.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- paxys 5y agoI don't see the relevance? Seatbelts, brakes, steering, engine all mean something completely different when on a passenger jet vs a sedan.
- jtbayly 5y agoWe don't have pilots in cars, so yes, it is very different.
- jdashg 5y agoYes, it is materially different, and they tackle wildly different problems in different fields, with again wildly different sensing and control interfaces, different uncertainties and challenges, and unbelievably disparate levels of required training, certification, and competence for use. The desire to name it "autopilot" stems from a desire for positive marketing, not a desire for technical correctness. (And certainly not from a desire to accurately convey limitations to users!)