4 ms·
Progressives are beginning to sound like those "if you build it they will come" conservatives who think the Republican Party would win if they just refocus on "
by rayiner 5y ago
Progressives are beginning to sound like those "if you build it they will come" conservatives who think the Republican Party would win if they just refocus on "fundamentals," like mandating Christianity.
The "ratchet effect" arises from the fact that the United States is a moderate country. If you look at the House popular vote over the last 20 years, Republicans have won it as often as Democrats. The House popular vote is a good metric to look at because it isn't affected by gerrymandering, and Republicans have an incentive to contest every single House seat (unlike with the Presidential popular vote, where Republicans have zero incentive to schlep all over rural California, New York, Illinois, etc., scrounging up votes).
Even within the Democratic Party itself, Biden decisively won the nomination. It's wasn't because of "electability." It's because the party is entirely dependent on minorities to be a viable national party, and American racial politics means that minorities often vote Democrat even if they are moderate to conservative. My parents are the "brown people" who turned Virginia blue. They liked Biden and disliked Warren. Not because of "electability" but because they're economically moderate and socially conservative, but as immigrants from a Muslim country they don't like Trump's rhetoric. That's the Democratic coalition, and progressives need to come to terms with that.
- tptacek 5y agoThe Republicans absolutely don't have an incentive to contest every single House seat (neither do the Democrats), and they don't. For instance, 2 cycles ago, an avowed neo-Nazi --- who literally stood on Chicago street corners in a Nazi uniform with a bullhorn --- took the GOP nomination for Lipinski's seat. That was possible because, at the time, running as a Republican against Lipinski was suicidal. The GOP did not contest that seat. Each cycle, both parties make red-to-blue and blue-to-red lists of districts to flip, and allocate money disproportionately to them. Even setting aside top-down party decisions, which clearly happen, seats aren't contested seriously for knock-on reasons: the best candidates won't run for hopeless seats, because the loss taints them and opens them up to carpetbagging charges when they try to contest other districts. I don't think I disagree with your whole analysis, but the argument that "Republicans have an incentive to contest every single House seat" clearly doesn't hold.
- rayiner 5y agoThat's fair. What I was trying to get at is that Republicans have more of an incentive to contest rural areas of blue states in House elections than in Presidential elections. There was zero Trump campaigning in my large Maryland county, even though Romney won it in 2012 and Trump came within two points in 2016.