4 ms·
> 2A is dead Huh? Democrats couldn't move the needle even a tiny bit on gun control, even with nominal control of all three branches and stuff like Sandy Hook
by ceejayoz 5y ago
> 2A is dead
Huh?
Democrats couldn't move the needle even a tiny bit on gun control, even with nominal control of all three branches and stuff like Sandy Hook as a rallying cry. The most meaningful gun regulation at the Federal level in the past few decades was Trump banning bump stocks.
There's zero reason to believe the current court - which is likely to be around for decades - will do anything but increase gun rights.
- notch656a 5y agoThe needle has been moved massively in NYC, California, Hawaii, all places where you need a permit just to exercise a right. The supreme court hasn't struck down the need for a permit to exercise a right (just to buy pistol in NYC or Hawaii). Nowhere in the country can you just drill the third hole in an AR and go at it without asking for permission. Nowhere in the country can someone with a federal felony [except some white collar trading crimes] exercise their second amendment right, even if all tehy did was illegally import a lobster. Nowhere in the country can you saw a 16 inch barrel down one inch without asking daddy for permission. Several states now require universal background check just to exercise a right (own a firearm). None of this has been strucken by supreme court. 2A is dead, now we just have a legacy of fairly liberal gun laws in certain circumstances and states.
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agowait until you learn that you need permits to protest and drive.
- notch656a 5y agoName a single place in US where you need a permit to buy a car or drive it on private property (which by the way, isn't an explicit right named in constitution as keeping and bearing arms is). Permit for a protest is also utter horseshit on par with restrictions on 2A.
- tablespoon 5y ago>> wait until you learn that you need permits to protest and drive. > Name a single place in US where you need a permit to buy a car or drive it on private property Even if you don't need a permit to back your car down your driveway (after someone with a permit has brought it to your home), you still need one to drive it anywhere anyone would actually want to go. So you effectively need a permit to drive.
- dahfizz 5y agoYou've entirely missed the point. You need a permit to drive _on public roads_. You don't need a permit to buy a car and only drive it on private property. Plenty of people have project cars that they tow to a race track / drag strip and don't need to register or license anything. This is obviously NOT analogous to the 2A, where you need licenses and registrations just to buy a gun. In an analogous situation to cars, you would not need a license to buy a gun and shoot it at a firing range. So the low effort quip "lol what about drivers licenses" that adgjlsfhk1 and many others make is not reasonable.
- tablespoon 5y ago> You've entirely missed the point. You need a permit to drive _on public roads_. No, I haven't. Driving on public roads is what most people mean by "drive."
- dahfizz 5y agoAnd shooting on private property is what most people use their guns for. So you agree that the licensing situation for driving and shooting is different.
- tablespoon 5y ago> And shooting on private property is what most people use their guns for. So you agree that the licensing situation for driving and shooting is different. I agree they are not precisely the same thing in all respects. However practically, the situations don't seem very different. >>> So the low effort quip "lol what about drivers licenses" that adgjlsfhk1 and many others make is not reasonable. It kind of is reasonable, given this sub-thread started with some pretty unreasonable or at least weird positions (e.g. 2A is "dead" apparently b/c everyone can't get a full-auto without a permit).
- otterley 5y ago1. Driving is not a Constitutional right, unlike the right to keep and bear arms. 2. While the First Amendment does protect speech, the Supreme Court has held that time/place/manner restrictions on speech can be created by the Government as long as there is a rational basis for them. Compare against content-based restrictions, which will be strictly scrutinized by the courts. Legal analysis is complicated and actions rarely fall into black-or-white categories. Even Second Amendment law has a large number of contours.
- notch656a 5y agoThe supreme court has also held that growing crops on your own private land to feed to your own animals is "interstate commerce." They're a laughable institution who's opinion should be promptly shit-canned.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]