3 ms·
Anything can be "just" anything else if you simplify it enough. The idea that humans are goalseeking systems motivated through a single parameter of dopamine r
by pjc50 5y ago
Anything can be "just" anything else if you simplify it enough.
The idea that humans are goalseeking systems motivated through a single parameter of dopamine response seems like it might be reasonable enough, but that then just moves the problem around: how is a particular set of stimuli + past stimuli linked to a dopamine response?
Furthermore, are they intending to force all behavior analysis through a control system with a single parameter? Can we ask questions like "what is the frequency response of the dopamine system?"
- datameta 5y agoAnother question is - what stimuli, changes in environment, or thought patterns affect dopamine levels and reuptake, and how? Also how do other neurotransmitters attenuate or floor/ceiling our behavior gamut in a way which modifies how we react to or are informed by dopamine levels and their rate of change. Essentially, if dopamine can be boiled down to a single lever, then I think that lever has as many buttons as a Formula 1 steering wheel.
- kortex 5y agoIt's definitely not a single parameter. I've been down this rabbit hole a bunch. There's actually 5 main subtypes of the dopamine receptor. They express in different concentrations in different brain regions, and have different functions. DRD2 is kind of the heavy lifter when it comes to goal seeking. If you had to boil it down to one idea, I'd call it "go/no go". It might be tempting to try to map D2 to something like a coefficient, perhaps even the "run coefficient" in run and tumble. But it's not at all like that, even on its own. It's very nonlinear. Furthermore, the action of D1 modulates D2 in a concentration-dependent way. So you have not just D2 signaling, D1 signalling, but also the differential signal as well. We don't know exactly how it maps out, but we know it plays a roll in weighing risk/reward ratios. Screwing with this pathway often results in "low risk low reward" mild manner folks switching to "high risk high reward", often going into gambling, manic spending, hypersexuality, and grandiose thinking. This can be seen occasionally with e.g. Parkinson's drugs such as L-DOPA. Actually my headcannon is there are some parallels between Parkinson's and control theory. Net loss of dopaminergic neurons results in lower bandwidth on your control loop. In PID loops, one of the symptoms of insufficient I/D gain is ringing, where the controller constantly hunts for the setpoint and overshoots. Tremor is a common symptom of Parkinson's (though it affects much more than just tremor), but if you notice, it's usually not a continuous tremor, it's only when trying to execute motor control, especially fine motor control. The body knows kinematically where it wants to be in space, but the feedback loop rings constantly as it isn't able to get sufficient bandwidth to error correct. Anyway, I think the point of TFA is not to suggest that this loop is a single parameter, it's just to model it as such. It's a spherical cow reduction. That kind of reduction lets you build practicable theories and test hypotheses. Such as: if Parkinson's is the result of reduced bandwith, can we treat the symptoms by increasing dopamine gain? And in fact, we can, that checks out.
- SubiculumCode 5y agoThe danger of people falling in love with an analogy. In simpler systems (cellular), it may be straightforward. In mice, you can say that their movement follows algorithmic predictions when only one goal is present (food), but I am sure that if you enter a second goal (avoid predator), and a third (procreate) into the same experiment, you will find that the algorithm will be insufficient...at least insufficient until you have some data reduction technique on the problem space.