4 ms·
> What am I missing? The fact that a correlation between religion and fertility rates is completely bollocks (with the notable exceptions of some extremist/fun
by mschuster91 5y ago
> What am I missing?
The fact that a correlation between religion and fertility rates is completely bollocks (with the notable exceptions of some extremist/fundamentalist sects of Christianity such as Quiverfull and Amish as well as fringes of the Jewish Ultra-Orthodox movement). High reproduction rates are closely linked to poverty [1], and once wealth rises in a country or people migrate from poor/high-rate countries, birth rates drop accordingly [2].
Additionally, it's a simple numbers game. The US only has 1% of Muslim faith [3], the European continent has ~7.5% [4] Muslims (of which 2/3rds belong to Russia and Turkey - the European Union figure is ~3.3%), even India barely has 13% [5]. It's mathematically impossible for Islam to achieve dominance in any country it doesn't already have by population in any feasible time scale, especially as religious affiliation in general keeps dropping and dropping associated again with wealth and education levels.
In general, the "the Muslims will replace us demographically!!!" take is dominantly found on the far-right end of the political spectrum, with the worst of the worst being the virulently anti-semitic "great replacement" theory that alleges that a "new world order" led by Jews wants to "replace" the intelligent White Christian population with dumb Muslims [6]. Please, don't fall for that kind of baseless, vile propaganda.
[1]: https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2016/aug/25/high-birth-rates-poverty-undermine-generation-african-children-odi-report https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2016/aug/25/h...
[2]: https://www.knomad.org/sites/default/files/2020-01/Migration%20Fertility%20Paper%20%282019%20Update_World%20Bank%29_final_-converted.pdf https://www.knomad.org/sites/default/files/2020-01/Migration...
[3]: https://www.pewforum.org/2021/01/14/measuring-religion-in-pew-research-centers-american-trends-panel/ https://www.pewforum.org/2021/01/14/measuring-religion-in-pe...
[4]: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_in_Europa#Statistik https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_in_Europa#Statistik
[5]: https://www.bpb.de/internationales/asien/indien/44418/muslime-in-indien https://www.bpb.de/internationales/asien/indien/44418/muslim...
[6]: https://www.adl.org/resources/backgrounders/the-great-replacement-an-explainer https://www.adl.org/resources/backgrounders/the-great-replac...
- dharmach 5y agoIt is not about plain fertility rate but tipping of demographic balance between communities by various means. It can create pockets of Muslim majority in countries where they are minority and then "right to self-determination" means partitions.
- mschuster91 5y ago> It can create pockets of Muslim majority in countries where they are minority I assume you're talking about the Parisian "banlieues", Berlin-Neukölln and similar areas? These ghettos are the result of a mixture of gentrification and (decades of) ethnic discrimination... basically, what happens is: First, many immigrants take up low-paid jobs in society because of language barriers or un-recognized qualification documents [1] or because of ethnic discrimination in hiring [2]. That means they are restricted to social/cheap housing by their low income. These housing situations (sometimes quickly) deteriorate in a phenomenon called "white flight", which leads to a vicious cycle of discrimination by city quarter [3] and everyone who is able to fleeing, leading to a collapse in rents and a subsequent rise in migrant and "down on their luck" (i.e. criminals and other people unable to find regular housing) people. In the end, the government and its services as well as economy (e.g. supermarkets, small shops, ...) also retreats from such areas, leading to further decline. The people left behind then go and self-organize - some in positive forms such as ethnic grocery exports/imports stores, some in negative forms such as crime gangs. The ethnic discrimination, especially against the young second- or third-generation migrants, also leads to a rise in gang-related crime: when schools fail to educate them, the employment market discriminates against them and cultural icons glorify a life of crime or crime is the only way to make a living without depending on social security, way too many choose the way of joining a gang. The crime then invites politicians, usually from the Conservative to far-right, to call for "law and order" tactics from police, which leads to an increase of discrimination by police, a further split between the immigrant and indigenous population and sometimes outright ethnic riots (the London 2011 riots began with the killing of a Black suspect by police, the Paris 2005 riots began with the death of two immigrant youth who fled from police in fear of lengthy "interrogations", and the BLM-associated riots were triggered by George Floyd being murdered by police). And historically, governments haven't exactly had a track record combatting the early signs of gentrification or ghettoization... which makes all the crying and complaining about "segregation", "parallel cultures" etc. when something happens (such as the mentioned riots, or the gang murder spree in Sweden) a bit cynical. The policies of the Conservative and far-right politicians created the very same problems they are now complaining about. [1]: https://www.spiegel.de/karriere/oecd-eu-studie-besonders-viele-migranten-arbeiten-fuer-niedrigloehne-a-1242825.html https://www.spiegel.de/karriere/oecd-eu-studie-besonders-vie... [2]: https://www.spiegel.de/lebenundlernen/schule/auslaendische-vornamen-migranten-diskriminierung-durch-firmen-bestaetigt-a-960855.html https://www.spiegel.de/lebenundlernen/schule/auslaendische-v... [3]: https://www.bpb.de/politik/innenpolitik/stadt-und-gesellschaft/64391/einfuehrung https://www.bpb.de/politik/innenpolitik/stadt-und-gesellscha...
- throwawaygal7 5y agoI think north west India would be a huge Muslim country if taken as an independent country, so dismissing it as 'just 13%' is kinda a funny dodge. Some European countries already have a plurality of births to migrant groups, I think the figure is better than 20% for Spain and France- so even if fertility euqalizes its a big demographic event considering the timescale.
- mschuster91 5y ago> Some European countries already have a plurality of births to migrant groups, I think the figure is better than 20% for Spain and France- so even if fertility euqalizes its a big demographic event considering the timescale. Spain has 10% people with migration history. It will take a lot of generations for that to change in a major way simply with fertility - and after three or four generations, it's hardly fair to call these people migrants anyway. In the US, a second-generation migrant became the 44th President and a third-generation migrant became the 45th President.
- maxerickson 5y agoIsn't "second-generation migrant" incoherent as a description of someone living in the country they were born in?
- mschuster91 5y ago"first/second generation migrant" is a widely used term in sociology and economy to detect and track differences between native and immigrant population. The term is common both in the US [1] and EU [2], with the latter actually going up to "third-generation migrant" when talking about long-term effects; the Swiss passed a special law to ease citizenship requirements for third-generation migrants. [3] [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigrant_generations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigrant_generations [2]: https://ec.europa.eu/home-affairs/pages/glossary/second-generation-migrant_en https://ec.europa.eu/home-affairs/pages/glossary/second-gene... [3]: https://www.admin.ch/gov/de/start/dokumentation/abstimmungen/20170212/bundesbeschluss-ueber-die-erleichterte-einbuergerung-von-persone.html https://www.admin.ch/gov/de/start/dokumentation/abstimmungen...