3 ms·
I'm of mixed feelings. On the one hand, it would be an incredible experience to eat what the natives ate. On the other hand, what they ate was tied up with th
by bitwize 5y ago
I'm of mixed feelings.
On the one hand, it would be an incredible experience to eat what the natives ate.
On the other hand, what they ate was tied up with the rest of their culture, especially hunting, gathering, and farming it themselves. And Professor You're-Nothing-But-Disease-Vectors-To-Me (also recently featured on Hackernews) had an interesting point about the commodification and commercialization of that which was sacred to Native Americans (talking about tobacco, not food). So maybe Native American restaurants should be not a thing. Maybe they will do nothing but corrupt the meaning food has in their society.
- duxup 5y agoI feel like Native American culture and people are almost unknown to most Americans. “Let’s not do that out of respect.” seems distantly/ unintentionally isolating and hiding a whole people / cultures out of fear of getting something wrong.
- WalterBright 5y agoIt's hard for it to be unknown, as we have so many place names from Native languages. Around here, we have Snohomish, Skycomish, Issaquah, Duwamish, Sequim, Tacoma and even Seattle. Many, many words in American English came from Native tongues.
- duxup 5y agoI don’t think place names are a good example of culture and people.
- WalterBright 5y agoLots of words: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_English_words_from_indigenous_languages_of_the_Americas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_English_words_from_ind... "or describe items of Native American or First Nations life and culture"
- bregma 5y agoIt's true. You can toboggan in Toronto, Ontario, Canada with a blood quantum of zero.
- JetAlone 5y agoIt's a legitimate concern. It will inevitably lead to some amount of "museum-ification"... It's ultimately up to the restauranteer, they will have to decide for themselves if preserving a sense of reverence towards their culture and its food is worth accepting the opportunity cost of not running such a business.
- mythrwy 5y agoThey have casinos now though. Also food (in my view) is shared heritage of humanity. It's never been static, diets change and we eat the best thing we have at the time. Including native peoples. I'm not sure food is a sacred tradition no one can emulate. Unless it's really not tasty then I'm ok leaving it as a sacred tradition in which I won't participate.
- elil17 5y agoTo me there’s a big difference between mass commercialization of American Indian foods and having more American Indian restaurants. I don’t think anyone thinks having a “Panda Express but for Indian food instead of Chinese” is a good idea. But if there’s a demand for Indian food, or if someone can create that demand, it’s a great opportunity for Indians to go and create some successful restaurants. Of course, someone has to figure out what exactly it is you serve at those restaurants. There’s been some work to define that on the fine dining end, which ends up looking like creative dishes that use indigenous ingredients, and on the diner/dive end of things, which is pretty much fry bread tacos and chili. When it comes to that middle zone, it’s hard to define something that’s both authentic and has good marketing. You can make shit up and do something along the lines of Mitsitam’s chocolate seared wild boar (listed as being from the “northern woodlands”, a region where chocolate does not grow) or you can serve actual Indian food like fry bread tacos, which is just going to remind all your white patrons that Indians mostly live in ghettos with little access to healthy food. I think it’s going to take some smart chefs to create menus that both market well and have genuine ties to American Indian cultures. I think there’s also room for Indian-owned companies to dominate the cured meats market. Any Indian company in that space would have a great story to tell around their product. There’s no reason people should be buying Jack Links beef sticks and not what would essentially be the same product but with American Indian ownership and branding.
- tomrod 5y agoCultures grow, evolve, synthesize, cull, and challenge. One thing they don't do is corrupt. There is not 100% "good" principle/attribute set against which all cultures have a clear yardstick.