4 ms·
This is better than any other speech-to-text setup I've ever encountered, for one simple reason: I followed the dead-simple install steps in the readme, started
by yjftsjthsd-h 5y ago
This is better than any other speech-to-text setup I've ever encountered, for one simple reason: I followed the dead-simple install steps in the readme, started the program, and it worked. Bonus points for the install being a git clone and pip install away. I don't know why this is a hard bar to clear, but bravo. (I suspect that it's because a lot of FOSS speech recognition is from academia where "follow the following 13 steps, including hand-crafting recognition parameters" is more normal and acceptable because everyone involved is already a domain expert, whereas I, as a user, just want "plug in a mic, run this thing, and get text on stdout".)
- melony 5y agoMost TTS and speech synthesis can be easy to install if you get rid of the GPU requirement. Both AMD and Nvidia have horrible workflows for installing their drivers and neural network/linear algebra kernels. Real time speech recognition/synthesis on generic consumer grade Intels/AMD cores is very, very difficult to do well which is why most providers are cloud based. (The alternative is targeting Mac only as they have standardized hardware everywhere)
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoYeah, text-to-speech is and has been easy for ages; I'm pretty sure I used espeak like a decade ago. On the other hand, I have tried... pretty much all the big names in speech-to-text, without success, or at best "I kind of got the demo to work but couldn't figure out how to do anything useful with it". Kaldi, sphinx, julius, a handful of tiny PoC things I found online... maybe I'm just bad at following instructions, or I'm trying to do something that they're not trying to optimize for, but I have not had a good time.
- johnisgood 5y ago> I followed the dead-simple install steps in the readme, started the program, and it worked. Bonus points for the install being a git clone and pip install away. I don't know why this is a hard bar to clear, but bravo. Woah, we really do write 2022.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoWhat?
- johnisgood 5y agoWhat you said used to be the standard. In fact, it used to be using your Linux distributions package manager which is even more convenient. I cannot even imagine a piece of software that you cannot get working as easily as cloning the git repository and then following the instructions, instructions that are typically pretty easy to follow and are supposed to work, or using a programming language's package manager, or your Linux distributions or BSD's package manager. At any rate, what I am trying to say is that if the case of having poorly documented (i.e. usually untested documentation) piece of software is high, then we definitely are doing something wrong. You should be able to follow the installation instructions and it should work, i.e. just read INSTALL or README and follow the instructions, like good old times! You said it yourself: "I don't know why this is a hard bar to clear, but bravo.". It should not be, it should be expected, and it should be done. It should not be a magical or surprising thing.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y ago(I am the OP you're talking about) Ah, yeah, very much agreed. I don't mind stuff not being packaged in official distro repos (although it would of course be very nice), but a build/install process being more complex than `configure && make && make install` borders on "bug" territory in my mind. In fairness, however, speech-to-text seems to mostly suffer from problems after the build/install step proper; it's common enough that getting to the point of running the program is okay, but it's useless without the language/speech models that make it actually understand speech, and those are... arcane, I think is the best word. Or huge files. A major differentiator for this one was that getting and using the model was "wget this single 40M file and place it here". And then at runtime, the program correctly grabbed the right microphone and automatically output text to stdout and was mostly accurate at doing so:) Others have done any one of those steps, but never all.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- MisterTea 5y agoYou used to be able to configure, make and then install software from source quite easily. Maybe you were missing devel a lib or two so you installed them. Now it's grown into a dependency hell that's so bad we now employ a myriad of package managers and container platforms to manage the disaster. I blame the package manager fetish.