6 ms·
I think more native american restaurants would be wonderful. But my eyebrows lift at the idea of "native american cuisine". We're talking about dozens of distin
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
I think more native american restaurants would be wonderful. But my eyebrows lift at the idea of "native american cuisine". We're talking about dozens of distinct cultures that covered the entire continent, from the damp, mild ocean adjacent pacific NW to the deserts of the southwest to the grasslands of the midwest to the forests of the east and north east (and so, so much more). Nobody would seriously suggest that there's any possibility of a unified food culture across this range.
So, let regional native american restaurants bloom!
- btmiller 5y agoI can imagine NA cuisine being no more unified than Mexican, Tex-Mex, New Mexican, Oaxacan, California Mexican, et. al. are under the category of “Mexican”. I grew up on Tex-Mex and I was dumbfounded at the sight of a wet burrito?? But you learn and grow :) and I’m sure any emergence of NA cuisine would be similar.
- AlotOfReading 5y agoThere's a lot more shared identity today as a result of colonization and the reservation system, which somewhat extends to things like food. Frybreads are a good example since they come directly from the reservation system and the typical ingredients provided by the government for cheap calories: flour, beans, oil, "cheese", and some form of meat, sugar, etc. Despite the common name, it's a shared culinary heritage for many tribes in the US. The real issue is that there's been very little widespread systematization of "traditional" indigenous cookery. We've started seeing that over the past few decades through the efforts of people like Lois Frank and many, many others, but it's a process.
- kevinmchugh 5y agoYeah, this is true and interesting, though I think a lot of (especially the high end) focus on Native American foods is on pre-Columbian cuisines. Btw, If anyone knows any pre-Columbian restaurants for Italian and Indian cuisines, let me know.
- vmception 5y ago> There's a lot more shared identity today as a result of colonization and the reservation system, which somewhat extends to things like food. Yes and this nearly amorphous identity is a tragedy that needs unbundling. Scratch the surface and none of it makes sense for any single pre-colonial culture on the whole continent. There are like 300 recognized distinct pre-colonial cultures here at the US federal level, most of which were grandfathered in before a cutoff for the reservation system and additional ones each requiring an act of Congress for recognition, even more at the state level, and even more vying for recognition as they are just noticing and regrouping after ages of separation, in a combination of forced separation or lineage dilution.
- 908B64B197 5y agoI can’t help but think there might be a more subtle resurgence of Native American Cuisine with more “authentic” Mexican food becoming more mainstream outside of coastal California and ethnic enclaves, as well as a renewed interest for Bison meat (20 years ago it was pretty rare). > There's a lot more shared identity today as a result of colonization and the reservation system, which somewhat extends to things like food. Frybreads are a good example since they come directly from the reservation system and the typical ingredients provided by the government for cheap calories: flour, beans, oil, "cheese", and some form of meat, sugar, etc. Despite the common name, it's a shared culinary heritage for many tribes in the US. At least this shared identity wasn't built over unmarked graves for children like elsewhere. [0] [1] [2] [0] https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/28/world/canada/kamloops-mass-grave-residential-schools.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/28/world/canada/kamloops-mas... [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/07/world/canada/mass-graves-residential-schools.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/07/world/canada/mass-graves-... [2] https://www.cnn.com/2021/06/24/americas/canada-unmarked-graves-discovered/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2021/06/24/americas/canada-unmarked-grav...
- jcranmer 5y ago> At least this shared identity wasn't built over unmarked graves for children like elsewhere. Don't kid yourself; the American boarding schools for the Native Americans weren't much better than the Canadian ones, were they any better to begin with. In general, I'd be hard-pressed to declare Canada any better or worse in its treatment of indigenous peoples than the US was--they were both pretty appalling.
- hydrok9 5y ago>At least this shared identity wasn't built over unmarked graves for children like elsewhere. It was....and not just children's graves, either.
- prescriptivist 5y ago> I grew up on Tex-Mex and I was dumbfounded at the sight of a wet burrito?? But you learn and grow :) Maybe for you. I, for one, will never accept rice in a burrito.
- zxcvbn4038 5y agoI remember when asking for “salsa” north of Denver resulted in your eggs being covered in ketchup - and having to get relatives to send me cans of hatch green chilies because pickled jalapeños were the only option in NYC. Things definitely got better, you can go pretty much anywhere in the US and get real salsa now - thank you taco bell for educating people. Today I can buy hatch green chilis in the ethnic isle of most grocery stores in NYC (and you can always order them from Amazon or Walmart). In the northeast poblano peppers are in all the Mexican-ish dishes - huge upgrade from the pickled jalapeños and very close to the hatch chilies I grew up with. Some of the stuff I get at the taco trucks is even more exotic and really wonderful - I’m a big fan of Oaxacan cheese, wish I had discovered that years ago.
- mythrwy 5y agoI think how it worked in pre contact times was you ate whatever you could get. Deer, squirrels, nuts, seeds from wild grasses, berries, tender hearts of succulents like agave, and if there was nothing else, the inner bark of pine trees. The gourmet scene probably didn't exist much before the rise of agriculture.
- bentpins 5y agoHIAKAI in New Zealand has done really well taking indigenous (traditionally foraged) Māori ingredients and turning them into a fine dining experience. I'd love to see what a similar take could look like with Native Indian cuisine. https://www.hiakai.co.nz/food https://www.hiakai.co.nz/food
- KittenInABox 5y agoFrankly the idea of discovering the palate of primarily locally foraged cuisine sounds exciting to me. I 100% want to know what talented chefs can do with agave hearts! How did native cuisine incorporate the wide varieties of berries in north america, in terms of color, texture, taste? It sounds like a whole philosophy of food that have no introduction to and I'd be excited to experience it.
- kevinmchugh 5y agoThe terms "Chinese food" and "Indian food" are similarly reductive/broad. They represent in the US a specific a new cuisine, a kind of curated fusion (eg chicken tikka masala). If your focus is on understanding the food of a place and people and how those things relate, this is a bad thing probably. As the market grows it kind of gets undone - this is most obvious in America with maybe Japanese restaurants? Sushi, ramen, bbq are often entirely different restaurants. Except that, as the fusion represents a new cuisine, it can stick around on its own
- ramraj07 5y agoI’m Indian and don’t see any problems with all Indian being mushed together into a single place. Honestly that’s par for course even in india, pretty much most restaurants label themselves as “multi cuisine” and make 5 different genres of Indian and fusion food. The question is if they’re still true to heart and make it taste good.
- screye 5y agoNot at all. In India, a Punjabi restaurant won't sell dosas and vice versa. Cuisines are incredibly local and the recipes change wildly depending on where you eat. The only exception is 'mom and pops veg restaurant' where the dishes are a Hodge podge of everything they can make. But these 'vanilla' dishes are usually there to pander to the customer and subpar. Their best dishes are usually the local speciality. Another exception is national chains like Haldirams, which make 'mediocre everything' and should not be a yardstick for anything indian. (Nothing against haldirams. Their Santra barfi is the best in the world as long as you buy it in the original nagpur location. They also run a few one-off speciality restaurants in Nagpur, which are quite good. But their national chain is meh) The sub-cuizinization of Indian food is already happening in the US. Godavari is an exclusively Udipi chain. Annapurna? in SJ and Kathakali in Seattle are top tier maharashtrian and Keralite restaurants. You now have Kathi and chat places with 1 page menus and cuisines from neighboring countries (Bangladeshi, Nepali, Srilankan) are finally being recognized as distinct. As a person for whom food is primary hobby, the idea that Indian or Chinese food gets put under one umbrella makes me rather annoyed. It does a disservice to the culture of civilizational behemoths.
- kerneloftruth 5y agoRegional, and/or Tribal.
- peanut_worm 5y agowell theyd at least generally share the same selection of ingredients because theyre all in north america. wont be seeing any old world vegetables.
- nanomonkey 5y agoStrangely enough there were tribes that refused to eat the same foodstuff as their neighboring tribes. People are funny about how they differentiate themselves from others. The Californian Native Americans prided themselves on being fit and not eating fatty foods, subsisting off acorns and wild grasses, where as the Pacific northwestern natives threw fat feasts known as potlatch. These would be wildly different restaurants.
- ThinkingGuy 5y agoDistinguishing one's tribe from the surrounding peoples by avoiding certain foods has a long history: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kashrut https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kashrut
- eyelidlessness 5y agoThe notion that there’s a common indigenous cuisine from the Americas is of course untenable. But there’s a commonality of cultural experience and history that binds a lot of native people and peoples together in a way that’s important. And may be more important than the particular fare offered at a particular restaurant. I welcome regional native restaurants too, but I also welcome solidarity among BIPOC and think that deserves celebration as well.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoDoesn't the commonality only really go back to the arrival of Europeans in the 1500s and onwards? Everything I read would suggest that before then, the different cultural groupings across north America would not have really seen themselves as particularly connected to each other, certainly not across large distances. If that's true (and I don't know if it is), then celebrating the commonality doesn't seem quite so obvious a thing to do.