3 ms·
I agree with the first part, but not the second. Agreed it would rule out some early filters. But for the second part, the ratio doesn't go to 1 in 200. That's
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
I agree with the first part, but not the second. Agreed it would rule out some early filters. But for the second part, the ratio doesn't go to 1 in 200. That's not how the anthropic principle works. You're already assuming that the Earth is extraordinary oh, so you can't just put it in the data set. Instead you would look at 199 out of 199 planets where sapient life capable of making an observation failed to develop.
Agreed that it provides no data on future filters ahead of us
- csee 5y ago> Agreed that it provides no data on future filters ahead of us This was my instinct, too, after reading both of your posts, but on reflection I think that it's unlikely to be no information. If we instead found 199 examples of extinct complex life (say, fossilized rodent-like creatures), instead of extinct simple life, we all probably agree that this would increase the odds of the filter being in front of us. Now, imagine gradually changing the example from extinct complex life (rodent-type creatures) and going down to extinct simple life. At what point in this thought experiment does it become "no data"?
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI guess I agree that discovering extinct life is information about probabilistic filters in earths future. I But, it does have to be weighed against the newly observed data supporting filters humans have already past. To take your example, as we keep finding rodent fossils, we become more confident that a filter exists between rat and rocket-men. As we go from 0 planets with rodent fossils to 1 trillion planets, the probability that this is the filter keeps going up. That is to say, we are not only decreasing the chance of pre-rat filters, but simultaneously increasing the chance that the filter is in the rat stage.