3 ms·
I must have gone to a pretty great school. We did experiments to prove the mitochondria are the powerhouse of the cell and we spent an entire 2.5 hour chemistr
by jedberg 5y ago
I must have gone to a pretty great school. We did experiments to prove the mitochondria are the powerhouse of the cell and we spent an entire 2.5 hour chemistry class on deriving avagrado's number and proving it was correct.
And this was public school in LA county in the 90s.
I see a lot of posts about "I'll bet you never saw/did/learned this in high school!" and almost every time the answer is, "yeah, actually I did". Like we were taught that Colombus massacred the locals, and we were taught that Native American's were treated poorly by European settlers.
So I guess I should be thanking my teachers for doing it right.
- jmercouris 5y agoI had a very similar experience in my school in the Chicago suburbs. I don’t know how it is elsewhere.
- MPSimmons 5y agoI grew up in West Virginia, and I can guarantee that virtually none of my teachers could explain how to derive most of what we were taught from first principles. There were a few very bright stars in my list of teachers, but most were really phoning it in and didn't understand well enough to teach anyone aside from reciting from the teacher's edition of the book.
- jl2718 5y agoI’m impressed that you had X-ray diffraction equipment in your high school chemistry lab. If not, then I’m pretty sure you were making some circular assumptions. The number was a purely theoretical unknown quantity to Avogadro himself, based only on the assumption that a fixed volume of gas should contain the same number of ‘molecules’ regardless of its composition. Oh and then there’s history. Wow, you honestly believe that just because you were taught the trendy woke parts of history that you got the whole story. I’ll pick an innocuous example. How much do you know about the Salem witch trials, and how much of that was taught from primary source evidence?
- jdaxe 5y agoWhat do you mean "The Crucible" doesn't count as a primary source??? ;)
- ziml77 5y agoNJ, high school in the 00's. When we had physics class, the schedule was set up so that once every few days, instead of going to gym class we'd have a double-length physics class for doing experiments. And this was for the normal physics class, not just AP physics. I don't know if they've expanded that lab day to cover other science classes. I think it would have been useful to have that extra time for the year that we did chemistry. Also have felt the same about those "things they don't teach you" posts. I may have done terribly in history because I suck with remembering names and dates, but I still can say for sure that we were not given a version of US history that made it all look perfect.
- starik36 5y agoI can only give my, "anecdotal", experience with my daughter and her friends that she studies with, who are currently in high school (also here in LA). The emphasis is 100% on memorizing things for the test. There are definitely no labs or experiments, cause Covid. If I asked any of them something deeper, like what were the causes of WW1, no one would be able to explain anything beyond the assassination in Serbia.
- perakojotgenije 5y ago> what were the causes of WW1, no one would be able to explain anything beyond the assassination in Serbia. And even that is wrong because the assassination happened in Bosnia (which was part of Austria-Hungary at the time)
- pie_flavor 5y agoBasically everyone who has ever heard 'you never learned in school that Columbus massacred the natives', did learn it in school. The purpose of this isn't to teach you what you didn't know, but to teach you to sneer at the upbringing of the people who still don't.
- mkipper 5y agoIn my experience (Canadian public school 20 years ago), schools _try_ to teach the scientific method, but I think the effectiveness is highly dependent on the school and teacher. I did countless science labs throughout school, and they all followed the scientific method: We were given a question, formed a hypothesis, performed experiments, analyzed the results and evaluated the correctness of our hypothesis. But this was never really described as the scientific method, or presented as some general framework you could apply to things in your life. It was just the series of steps you had to follow in science labs. Now, some kids might be able to bridge the gap between this process and the facts they read in textbooks. When you're presented some fact in biology class, it's because people have followed that same process iteratively to reach that conclusion. But in my experience, bridging that gap was left up to the student. Some kids figured it out, but I'd wager that most didn't.