3 ms·
> If we were to increase the minimum wage 10x, what do you think would change about the economy? If we increased the minimum wage 10x and somehow that policy w
by zozbot234 5y ago
> If we were to increase the minimum wage 10x, what do you think would change about the economy?
If we increased the minimum wage 10x and somehow that policy was binding, there would be a whole lot of involuntary unemployment, workers' overall income would plummet and we would have a deep economic depression. But there's nothing that suggests such effects from an economically viable UBI. Such an UBI would barely be enough for subsistence, possibly not even that, so people would still choose to work if only to acquire some disposable income. For every single thing that 'ceased to be done' because of increased expenses, there would be growing employment in some other, higher-productivity sector.
- Kim_Bruning 5y agoDidn't Henry Ford actually do something like this for his own workers? He paid a much higher wage than his competitors, on the argument that his own workers should be able to afford the factory's products.
- zozbot234 5y agoHe paid high wages because he was in fact offering highly-skilled work for his time, a bit like Elon Musk is doing today. The "our workers should be able to afford the product" thing was a clever meme/bit of marketing. (In fact, I would argue that high-paying manufacturing jobs have always required some degree of skill, even when this kind of manufacturing work was especially common in the West.)
- Kim_Bruning 5y agoThis is why I don't feel bad about replacing people doing boring work by robots. They now get the somewhat more interesting work of operating the robots.
- tekknik 5y agoOnly if they have interest in operating the robots, and the intelligence. If they don’t have either one of those, nope, they just lost a job because of your decision.
- Kim_Bruning 5y agoMaybe I've gotten lucky with machine operators so far. The ones I've met are intelligent, though their locus of intelligence is in their thumbs. Someone on a project needs to have it there, so that's just fine by me!
- tekknik 5y agoBut you get how you’re changing their life for a decision they didn’t make right?
- Kim_Bruning 5y agoDepends on the company maybe? Were you in a project that went bad? Last time I did a robot project, the people who would ultimately be the machine operators were involved every step of the way, learning and building together with the team. I'm not sure how installing a handful of machines in one small corner of a huge factory that's already full of machines would somehow change someone's entire life. Hopefully it does make it a little easier though!
- tekknik 5y ago> Depends on the company maybe? Were you in a project that went bad? I have never worked in robotics, save for hobby drones and hexapods. The question is not whether we would enjoy it, it’s whether someone else will. You seem very convinced that you should decide what people do for work. That’s the part I’m trying to get across to you, you should not have that power for anybody but yourself.
- Kim_Bruning 5y ago