4 ms·
> the (solid) angle at each vertex; it starts constant (1/2 pi radian in 2D, 1/2 pi steradian in 3D) Unstudied curiosity: steradians seem to be defined in term
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
> the (solid) angle at each vertex; it starts constant (1/2 pi radian in 2D, 1/2 pi steradian in 3D)
Unstudied curiosity: steradians seem to be defined in terms of the point of a cone. But the corner of a cube is the intersection of several (for a cube, 3) planes, not a cone. How do you do the calculation of steradians?
- wlesieutre 5y agoCone is one scenario to think about, but what it really comes down to is the fraction of the full sphere that your solid angle includes. To make a 2D analogy, you can think of 2D angles as a portion of a circle represented as a fraction of 2pi radians. Cut it in half and you have pi radians, cut that in half (so a quarter of the circle) and you have pi/2 radians, or 90 degrees. That 90 degrees "quarter of a circle" example is looking at it as the "point of a pie slice", but it's the same 90 degree 2D angle as you have in the corner of a square. You can look at the corner of a cube the same way. The full sphere of solid angle is 4pi, a hemisphere is 2pi. Now take that hemisphere and cut it into quarters (1/8ths of a sphere). Each of those quarters is pi/2 steradians, and the solid angle at the center is the same solid angle represented by 1/8th of the sphere is the same solid angle you have at the corner of a cube. Or to put it another way, you could pack the corners of 8 cubes around a point and it would leave no empty gaps, so the corner of each cube is occupying 1/8th of a "full" 4pi steradians.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThanks, that was helpful in thinking about it.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoNow that I've thought about it, I don't think we're on solid ground measuring pointiness in n-dimensional radians. A perfectly non-pointy angle in 2D is half the circle, or π radians. A perfectly non-pointy angle in 3D is half the sphere, or 2π steradians. π is less than 2π, but the straight-line 2D angle is not sharper than the flat-plane 3D angle. What's relevant to the pointiness is the proportion of the sphere, not the numeric value of the surface area.
- wlesieutre 5y agoIt corresponds to area if and only if you're talking about a unit sphere. In the same way that an angle of pi radians corresponds to pi length around the perimeter of a unit circle, but if you're measuring on the perimeter of a larger circle you'll have a correspondingly larger length. The "4pi steradians in a sphere" comes from the area of a unit sphere (4×pi×r^2 = 4×pi). I've never had cause to use 4+ dimensional solid angle for anything, but you'd determine full n-dimensional radians the same way, I guess with a 4-dimensional sphere the "surface area" is a 3D volume on the perimeter of the 4D unit sphere's space?
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> In the same way that an angle of pi radians corresponds to pi length around the perimeter of a unit circle, but if you're measuring on the perimeter of a larger circle you'll have a correspondingly larger length. I understand this. It's not what I'm talking about. There was a claim upthread that the corner of a square and the corner of a cube are equally sharp because (1) one of them is π/2 radians; (2) the other is π/2 steradians; and (3) π/2 is equal to π/2, hence equally sharp. I'm saying I don't think this can be right, because when we consider two angles that we know are equally sharp, the 2D flat line and the 3D flat plane, one of them is π and the other is 2π, so unit-free radian measurements cannot be a valid measure of sharpness. The radian measurement needs to be normed against the full sphere in an equal number of dimensions, so that the flat line equals 1/2 (of a circle) and the flat plane equals 1/2 (of a sphere). I want to conclude that these two angles are equally sharp because 1/2 is equal to 1/2. But even if I can't do that, I need to avoid concluding that a flat line is twice as sharp as a flat plane, because I know that's untrue. But my reasoning would tell us that the corner of a cube is twice as sharp as the corner of a square, 1/8 to 1/4.
- wlesieutre 5y agoAh gotcha. I'm not even sure it's meaningful to compare the "relative pointiness" of angles between different dimensions. It's like trying to compare whether the area of a circle is bigger or smaller than the volume of a sphere. And then what if I only have 70% of a circle, but 80% of the sphere? You could make up some metric like "the unit sphere occupies a greater volume fraction of the unit cube compared to the area fraction of a unit circle in a unit square", and compare like that if you only have some fraction of each circle/sphere instead of the whole thing, but is there any value in making that comparison?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]