9 ms·
> Guaranteed income (GI) would at least buffer some of the anxiety. I could also see businesses knowing it existed would cut worker hours to part-time. But if p
by godelski 5y ago
> Guaranteed income (GI) would at least buffer some of the anxiety. I could also see businesses knowing it existed would cut worker hours to part-time. But if part-time plus GI was enough then the worker has the power.
This is the biggest advantage I see, and shows why you wouldn't even need a living wage. You need a sufficient amount of money so that if a worker is being abused they can say "fuck it, I quit" and be able to live until they find another job. Being able to do that should prevent a fair amount of abuse in the first place.
- manicdee 5y agoHow can they afford to quit if they aren’t earning enough to live on in the first place? You have that luxury because of savings.
- godelski 5y agoEven a small amount of income gives breathing room. That's the idea here. A full UBI would mean there's no chance of suffocating. I'm saying that we can dip our toes in first and we should still see effects. It isn't an all or nothing scenario as many put forward.
- HowTheStoryEnds 5y agoOnly if all costs and prices remain the same as before the ubi and that seems a ridiculous pipe dream.
- bwb 5y agoI don't get it... why not raise minimum wages to reflect local cost of living? IE, why tax all of us instead of the businesses not paying enough for their employees?
- jakelazaroff 5y agoIn that scenario, you’d still need to work. Basic income increases workers’ bargaining power because they can quit without losing their entire income.
- kukx 5y agoAnd their income will grow on trees. It will fail unless the government gets easy money from eg producing oil like Emirates. Otherwise someone needs to produce stuff. We already have a big inflation problem that is directly related to policies that rain money on those not working. Let's not make things even worse, please.
- SketchySeaBeast 5y ago> We already have a big inflation problem that is directly related to policies that rain money on those not working. Do we have any sort of evidence for that claim?
- kukx 5y agoOf course. Printing money inflates its supply. And increasing the demand for products (by providing easy money) without increasing the supply of products (and actually decreasing it by restricting work) will lead to higher prices. It is economics 101 and it was tested by many countries eg Germany before the WW or more recently Venezuela.
- SketchySeaBeast 5y agoSorry, yes, printing money leads to inflation. I was asking for evidence that "We already have a big inflation problem that is directly related to policies that rain money on those not working." is the source of a large portion of inflation instead of the multitude of other reasons that money is printed. Of the recent $4 trillion coronavirus payout, only about a fifth of that went to workers or their families[1], and even that isn't all to people who aren't working. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2020/business/coronavirus-bailout-spending/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2020/business/corona...
- kingkawn 5y agoWe all get taxed either way, might as well be to the benefit of people rather than abstract organizations like businesses.
- staticassertion 5y ago> why tax all of us Because it impacts all of us. Imagine the impact on crime and homelessness if there were UBI. Quality of life would improve for everyone. I'm happy to pay my taxes if it goes to that.
- HowTheStoryEnds 5y agoThe problem is that it takes a strict authoritarian governmental control because you need to regulate the prizes of everything that's deemed necessary to prevent subsidizing controlling third parties. Take housing for instance: rent would rise a lot when people suddenly get x more. People pay because they have no choice so the x transfers directly to the controlling third party in the end, completely negating any possible benefit but for those already in a non-vulnerable position.
- staticassertion 5y agoI don't think rent control is the policy of a "strict authoritarian government". Regardless, I don't agree with you that rent would rise considerably or that it would negate any benefit.
- HowTheStoryEnds 5y agoWhy would rent not rise? Landlords know you have X more to spend now. Why would they not raise prices, altruism? You think that's their reason behind renting out property? Same with the telecommunications pseudo-monopolies: you really think they won't try and tap into that resource even if a little? Communications has become almost as vital as housing the last decade. Companies will do everything they can and the public is capable of paying to increase their revenue. Also: depends on how you define 'rent control'
- wlecometo 5y agoBecause people can decide to go live in another place, quit their job and get another one in the new place. One of the reason some people do not move is due to being comfortable and at travel distance to their job. Under this light you can see what happened to several European cities with high rent due to University: as soon as Covid made students go home to their parents as classes were online, there was a huge drop in rent prices.
- dghughes 5y agoYou could bundle welfare, food stamps, other social programs, medicare, etc. add a tax break/no tax for anyone making less than $20K. Put it all into one system and call it UBI. You the tax payer are still paying the same thing.