3 ms·
"The US government's approach to measuring poverty" is, well, just that. It is not the one true objective definition of poverty. If you are going to accept that
by jerf 15y ago
"The US government's approach to measuring poverty" is, well, just that. It is not the one true objective definition of poverty. If you are going to accept that as a definition of "poverty", it actually removes all incentives to "fight" poverty, because it's impossible to move the needle. If you somehow beat poverty back 5%, the government's going to move the line up to make up for it. As a government measure, it's fine. As the One And True Philosophical and Cultural Definition of Poverty, it's worthless, because the government won't let us "beat" poverty back to the point that it doesn't exist anymore.
Because if it would let us do that, we'd already have done it.
Your "absolute" terms are still relative, because you can't get around the fundamental and massive changes in technology in all forms across all of society.
Government definitions are suitable for government work, no sarcasm or reference to popular sayings intended. They are not suitable for philosophical debating; all the fact that legal poverty going up really means in the end is that we are in an economic downturn, not that anything (else!) fundamental has changed at the societal level. This isn't a special "poverty" problem, it's just another phrasing of the recession(/depression).
- dalke 15y agoThe reason for the US definition of poverty, founded as it is in the "War on Poverty", is precisely because it is absolute. Quoting again from that Wikipedia article: "Since [the Orshansky Poverty Thresholds] measure was absolute (i.e., did not depend on other events), it made it possible to objectively answer whether the U.S. government was "winning" this war." Your argument about "one true objective definition of poverty" is pointless. What you're arguing is that since we're materially better off than the Middle Ages, no one is poor anymore. You want to throw the word "poor" out the window, while I want to say that the word has real meaning, and that meaning is "lacking the resources to meet the basic needs for healthy living; having insufficient income to provide the food, shelter and clothing needed to preserve health." Your disdain for the government is clear, but without justification since any statement you make can be rejected with an equally disdainful comment on its originator. Better would be to point out how most families of four, making under $22,350 a year really have no problems meeting those basic needs. Books like "Nickel And Dimed" suggest otherwise. I look forward to your large scale research which clearly refutes such anecdotal evidence.
- lotharbot 15y ago> "What you're arguing is that since we're materially better off than the Middle Ages" No -- what he's arguing is that we're materially better off than the periods of time in which you and the article are trying to compare to. It's dishonest to make a comparison to some decades ago and then complain when others make comparison to those same time periods. The word "poor" does have real meaning -- but its meaning is relative. 1959 poor and 2009 poor are not the same thing. The measures used to define poverty (and inflation) are not absolute, objective, or static, despite what wikipedia claims.
- dalke 15y agoNo, I'm trying to argue that 1) the definition that the US uses was chosen precisely because it isn't relative and can be used to judge of the "War on Poverty" has been won, 2) that being better off materially is only one aspect of being poor; shelter and health are two other factors, and 3) choosing a purely material, absolute definition, doesn't make sense since if you go back in time then everyone was poor. And I refuse to say that Louis XIV was poor simply because he didn't have air conditioning. While someone who has to decide between food and rent money, despite having a plasma TV bought two years ago, before losing a job due to protracted illness, is poor. There's a simple resolution to this - what do you define as poor? How many people in the US do you consider are poor? Are people now significantly less poor than they were in 1970, and how do you measure that? Since you don't like the baseline of Wikipedia, I point you to the US Census Department at http://www.census.gov/hhes/povmeas/publications/orshansky.html#C2 http://www.census.gov/hhes/povmeas/publications/orshansky.ht... (next two paragraphs) Orshansky accurately described her poverty thresholds as a "relatively absolute" measure of poverty(60), inasmuch as they were developed from calculations that made use of the consumption patterns (at a particular point in time) of the U.S. population as a whole. (In the dichotomy between relative and absolute definitions of poverty, one of the essential characteristics of a purely "absolute" definition of poverty is that it is derived without any reference to the consumption patterns or income levels of the population as a whole.(61)) However, while Orshansky's poverty thresholds were not a purely absolute measure, they were also quite clearly not a purely relative measure, such as the 50-percent-of-median-income measure proposed by Britain's Peter Townsend in 1962 and (in the United States) by Victor Fuchs in 1965.(62) The relativity is that the definitions assume that 1/3rd of income goes to food, which was the case in the 1950s. That is less now, while housing and transportation/energy costs are higher. So okay, yes, there's some relativity in the definition, but it isn't by far a relative definition.