3 ms·
To be clear, in my experience it's worse now than pre-2016, and still a very serious problem.
by wolverine876 5y ago
To be clear, in my experience it's worse now than pre-2016, and still a very serious problem.
- bee_rider 5y agoRecent events have emboldened racists for sure, but the original comment was that we've gone off the rails since the King speech, which is a comparison to the Civil Rights Era US. Is it your experience that the post-2016 era is worse than that? I'm white and I wasn't alive at the time, so it isn't my place to judge there, but I'd find that pretty surprising I guess.
- wolverine876 5y ago> the original comment was that we've gone off the rails since the King speech, which is a comparison to the Civil Rights Era US. Is it your experience that the post-2016 era is worse than that? I'm white and I wasn't alive at the time, so it isn't my place to judge there, but I'd find that pretty surprising I guess. I wasn't there either. Lots of African-Americans I've spoken to think we are going backward. As a simple example, the Voting Rights Act has been rolled back, and many segregation-era voting restrictions restored. And regardless, the comparision doesn't matter. Better or worse than the early 1960s is not a standard (and it would be a very low one), and does nothing to address what is happening today.
- bee_rider 5y agoI think I for the most part agree with you. I think we're talking past each other because you are arguing for a reasonable comparison (recent US to current US), while I was arguing against the specific unreasonable comparison made in the original comment -- some imagined version of King's objective based on taking a single line of one out of his speeches vs the modern US. Sidenote -- I'm not sure why you cut my quotes where you do. This most recent one changes the meaning of my sentence significantly by removing "but the original comment was that," which makes it clear that I'm responding to a specific argument. In fact, the quote you've come up with makes it look like I'm making the claim that I'm arguing against.
- wolverine876 5y ago> I'm not sure why you cut my quotes where you do. This most recent one changes the meaning of my sentence significantly by removing "but the original comment was that," which makes it clear that I'm responding to a specific argument. In fact, the quote you've come up with makes it look like I'm making the claim that I'm arguing against. Sorry, just not being careful. I fixed it. > I think I for the most part agree with you. / I think we're talking past each other ... I did not mean to convey disagreement; I thought we mostly agreed too, in the same way you say, I was just exploring the topic. Apparently I need to be more careful with my writing today!
- bee_rider 5y agoNo worries -- I think I was in a defensive mindset because the original comment that kicked everything off appeared to be pulling an annoying rhetorical technique.