3 ms·
Generally a good idea, but probably not necessary for permanent installation (or allotment since they are portable), just during HVAC design and testing. Also,
by giantg2 5y ago
Generally a good idea, but probably not necessary for permanent installation (or allotment since they are portable), just during HVAC design and testing.
Also, if the kids are wearing masks then the cognitive benefits go out the window with CO2 concentration being above 20,000ppm.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33858372/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33858372/
- netizen-936824 5y agoSomething interesting about that study: the CO2 levels are okay for short term use Students are wearing them literally all day
- ahaucnx 5y agoWith a permanent installation you can link the sensor CO2 data with the hvac system for a demand controlled ventilation. This will allow energy savings and maintain an optimum level of CO2 in the classrooms. We often see big differences in our data comparing different classroom sizes, age of students and activities inside the classroom. So often a fixed hvac setting is not the best solution.
- giantg2 5y ago"With a permanent installation you can link the sensor CO2 data with the hvac system for a demand controlled ventilation." That may be the best greenfield solution. Yet this is not a greenfield situation. These sensors are assigned to the school, but they are not permanently installed, and they cannot control the systems. Most existing systems aren't even capable of being controlled that way.
- vertnerd 5y agoAs someone who wears a kn95 mask all day I think the results of linked study should be taken with a grain of salt. The CO2 concentrations they measured with conventional masks are effectively similar to the concentrations in exhaled air, which means they may only be measuring the concentration in the stale air sitting inside the mask between each inrush of fresh air that occurs with each inhalation. In other words, I don't care what the CO2 concentration is in my mask. I care what the average concentration is in each inhaled breath, which consists of the stale air in my mask, combined with the (presumably larger volume of) fresh air that is introduced by breathing in. I doubt the study methodology properly captured that.
- giantg2 5y agoThat's largely irrelevant if you look at the constraints of the system we are discussing. 1- the beneficial level in the article is to keep CO2 under 800ppm for learning benefit. 2- tidal volume in adults is 400-500ml. 3- volume inside an N95 varies based on model and face geometry, but is presumably 20ml or much larger, especially for children with smaller faces. 4- indoor CO2 concentrations are typically not lower than 600ppm. Based on this info, average concentration easily exceeds 1000ppm. This is even more likely for children who have smaller tidal volumes and presumably more volume under the mask.
- vertnerd 5y agoI think your take is fine, but it's a far cry from saying we're spending the day at the 15 minute limit for CO2 concentration. The classroom I teach in easily hits the 1000 ppm level (I measured it at the start of the 2020-21 school year), so we're already suffering before the masks go on. The masks just make it a little bit worse.
- jve 5y ago> 4- indoor CO2 concentrations are typically not lower than 600ppm. Out of curiosity, just looked at my PPM monitor behind my laptop... it reads 600 :) We have a good ventilation here. But humidity suffers (very low)
- r_hoods_ghost 5y agoThis is the UK. Even in modern buildings you often don't need air conditioning since the climate is temperate, although that's beginning to change. Forget about retrofitting air con in the average Victorian or 1960s era school, they're just not designed for it.