5 ms·
Why are air combat kills so rare? (2017)
- fnord123 5y agoBehind an illegal cookie popup.
- a3w 5y ago„Reader view“ in some browsers removed the banner, but not the text content.
- Readywater 5y agoFox 2 Do you consent to us using your HUD telemetry for post mission analysis? The f… FOX 2 Do you consent to us using your HUD telemetry for post mission analysis? HOW DO I SAY YES?!
- a3w 5y agoYou missile will launch after this ad for… Thomson‘s Coffins! Burying Tommys for decades! No unhappy customers!
- jacquesm 5y agoSkip this ad in 5... 4... 3...
- skocznymroczny 5y agoDrink verification can to launch missile
- Besticle 5y agoBBC doesn't do adverts.
- Milner08 5y agoIt doesn't do adverts inside the UK. Outside the UK they do. I always get a bit confused when I access it via the work VPN and see adverts!
- closewith 5y agoThey do serve ads to users outside the UK. I opened the article in a fresh instance of Chromium and counted 13 ads in the article - some very intrusive and others mixed in with the related articles (although with an "ADVERTISEMENT" label).
- chrisseaton 5y agoI’m afraid they do. Never been outside the UK and tried to access the BBC?
- jzellis 5y agoBecause you're trying to shoot something flying at 500 miles an hour, piloted by a tiny lunatic who actually thought this sort of thing was a good career move and is probably on military-issued meth, with a projectile the size of your thumb, while also being the exact same sort of lunatic? :-D
- notahacker 5y agoBut if your missiles are effective enough, they take care of the bit about finding and hitting the target for you. The article explains it as enemy forces not having anyone loony enough to think actually getting within range is going to advance their career. I blame Joseph Heller.
- gilleain 5y agoWell concern for one's safety in the face of dangers that are real and immediate is the process of a rational mind.
- ashtonkem 5y agoThe issue with the missiles is that the other side also has them, and is quite keen to use theirs without being hit by yours. Combatants have a way of learning to neutralize each other’s advantages, and claims of weapon system capabilities are almost always overstated.
- _benj 5y agoHave been watching videos of DCS World (which btw, seem to do a pretty good job as a simulator) and it’s just precisely like you described. I’d say that a simulator is marginally less “lunatic” but still :)
- bencollier49 5y agoThe "Grim Reapers" videos are great fun. Love watching them occasionally with my sons.
- 5y ago
- josephkern 5y agoWhy are we discussing an article from 2017 with no real information besides, USA number 1? Asymmetry is the key to airpower, if you don't have it you won't have it. Look-first shoot-first is only one kind of asymmetric advantage.
- ARandomerDude 5y ago> Asymmetry is the key to airpower No -- it can't be possible! I always hear people say "flexibility is the key to airpower." I feel so lost.
- josephkern 5y agoJohn Boyd and Ben Rich would both disagree with the concept of "flexibility".
- JohnWhigham 5y agoTLDR: Because SAMs have gotten so good at their jobs, air forces don't even bother.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoThe article doesn't say that anywhere.
- sokoloff 5y agoThe article talks entirely about air-to-air combat and the imbalance caused by the superior beyond-visual-engagement capabilities of major air powers. It says nothing about surface-to-air missiles.
- AdrianB1 5y agoIt's mostly because conflicts are rare. The conflicts of the past 20 years were very small and asymmetrical in nature, there was no open conflict between 2 militaries that both have significant air power.
- sklargh 5y agoAir to air combat kills are rare because the strategic circumstances that would make them numerous enough to be unexceptional would likely tree up to minor-to-major nuclear conflict. More directly, am struck that the average person has yet to internalize that in modern high-intensity conflict detection roughly = mission kill if not outright destruction. Everything operationally important (air, sea, ground) that wants to survive needs to avoid emission/detection long enough to detect something else first and destroy it.
- the__alchemist 5y ago> More directly, am struck that the average person has yet to internalize that in modern high-intensity conflict detection roughly = mission kill if not outright destruction. Everything operationally important (air, sea, ground) that wants to survive needs to avoid emission/detection long enough to detect something else first and destroy it. Only if you're willing to go in the enemy's weapons engagement zones - whether that's a fighter or surface-based system. Detection/track ranges are generally much higher.
- Tuna-Fish 5y ago> Detection/track ranges are generally much higher. This is absolutely not true. For modern weapons, the effective range is generally limited by detection, whether you are talking about heavy SAM (like the S-400, with it's 400km range) or modern AAM (like the Meteor or R77M, with ranges ~200km). As a rule, it's relatively cheap and easy to increase missile range, so they are not limited by ability but by choice. SAM ranges are pushed past reasonable detection ranges because it allows siting the missiles more to the rear, which is safer, and for the missile batteries to provide mutual support. AAM ranges are pushed past detection to increase the size of the no-escape zone, which is usually thought to be more important than the actual maximum range.
- the__alchemist 5y agoI'm not sure where you're getting those numbers, but your ranges are off by an OOM. Maybe if you're talking a lofted shot from high speed, high alt against a non-maneuvering target, with low PK expectations.
- MisterTea 5y agoA thought about dog fights: As they fire large heavy rounds at each other (.50 BMG or bigger), have there been any accounts of ground casualties or damage from these stray rounds? Or do the bullets lose too much velocity (the .50 BMG has been shown to be effective up to 3+km)? I'd imagine the odds of getting hit are VERY slim but not impossible.
- krisoft 5y agoI'm not sure about ground casualties but there is a story about a Grumman F11 which run into its own bullets: https://www.planeandpilotmag.com/news/pilot-talk/2021/10/04/grumman-f11-tiger-shoot-itself-down/ https://www.planeandpilotmag.com/news/pilot-talk/2021/10/04/...
- thereddaikon 5y agoThey are rare because its rare for air forces to meet in the air. Last time that happened at any real scale was 30 years ago in ODS. Since then the active air forces of the west have been dropping bombs on groups like ISIS who don't have fighters. And even in ODS there weren't that many A2A kills because most Iraqi aircraft were destroyed on the ground.
- skhr0680 5y ago1. Fighter jets in battle-ready condition are rare to start, even more so one flying in the right spot at the right time to shoot down a hostile jet 2. No one is dumb enough to even try fighting US jets with their own. US have the best aircraft, missiles, and more flying hours than anyone else
- vagrantJin 5y ago> US have the best aircraft, missiles, and more flying hours than anyone else Well said. That arrogance must come in handy for bombing goat herders in the desert.
- juanani 5y ago[dead]
- GoodbyeMrChips 5y agoThe drones are for bombing wedding parties. (The reader may wish to let that sentence sink in). Link: https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=drone+wedding+party https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=drone+wedding+party
- twobitshifter 5y ago2* no one the us has gone to war with.
- secondcoming 5y agoI believe there were regular dogfights during the Falklands War in the 1980's.
- greedo 5y agoThe air combat in the Falklands was largely interceptions, not dogfights. The British used Sea Harriers and the GR3 Harriers, both of which have surprising agility. They were challenged with stopping attacks from the Argentine Navy and Air Force that were targeting the RN ships transporting the RN Marines. There were three primary Argentine aircraft used in the conflict; the Super Entendard, the Dagger (an Israeli Mirage derivative) and the A-4 Skyhawk. The Super Entendard gained fame because of its successful use of the Exocet ASM. It never engaged in A2A combat with any British forces. The Daggers and Skyhawks could have tried to engage the Harriers, but that wasn't their mission tasking. They carried nothing but bombs and attacked the RN ships (sinking 7 and damaging many more). They were operating at the very edge of their range, and didn't have enough fuel to do more than skim in, drop bombs, and flee. The Skyhawks had airborne refueling capabilities, but this was very limited since the Argentines only had 2 tankers.
- pjc50 5y ago> "After the totally lopsided kill-to-loss ratio attained by the US Air Force and US Navy during the First Gulf War, it is a very rare thing for regimes under attack by the US and its allies to send fighters up in defence - since they know how it will end." Symmetric warfare is old hat. It's all asymmetric warfare now: https://www.cnbc.com/2022/01/17/yemens-houthis-claim-suspected-drone-attack-on-uae-tankers.html https://www.cnbc.com/2022/01/17/yemens-houthis-claim-suspect... ("tanker" appears to mean "truck" rather than "ship" in this context, and "drone" is probably the small quadcopter style rather than what the USAF means by "drone")
- ho_schi 5y agoThis is true. And this holds up until enemy forces have advanced electronic warfare capabilities. Radar and radio jammers are usual in modern warfare. And the worst case is an EMP. The Russians considered elctronic warfare already in the Russo-Japanese War. During WWII the British jammed the German radio navigation. Technology isn't making you automatically superior - you need to able to able apply it. And if not, a reliable fallback is needed. Remember the F4 which initially had no internal cannon because the US believed the "superior" rockets will do everything? It didn't worked well in Vietnam. The internal cannon is a feature of every modern fighter and the Navy founded TOPGUN. I've no clue what happens in future. But I would keep a close look on who is doing well with electronic protection (EP). And we didn't speak about the elephant in the room, computer networks. Which are hopefully autonomous without the need of an network support. Don't connect anything important - like a fighter aircraft - to a network.
- raducu 5y agoI'm sure at some point there were soldiers who could have used a sword or bayonet, but eventually those were not needed anymore. The same with cannons in fighter planes.
- twobitshifter 5y agoI think fighter jets will go extinct some time in the near future. The maneuvering, speed and stealth of drones will soon outdo any manned fighter because they’ll push beyond the limits of human physiology. Even more, the cost of the drones will be cheaper.
- ericbarrett 5y agoAgreed; in fact I think we're already there and the only reason the human pilot hasn't shaken out of the equation is lack of a large-scale war to prove how ineffective they are. If there was such a conflict—and it somehow avoided going nuclear—who would win, the side that can make a few hundred fighters and trained pilots a year, or the side that can crank out 10,000+ drones in a month?
- raducu 5y agoWe could go a step further and think robot infantry soldiers, but airplanes are easier to automate. I'm sure that if the same effort was put into self-driving self-shooting tanks as in teslas, the result would be more than adequate vs humans.
- ericbarrett 5y agoNot robot infantry (we're a long way from that) nor automated tanks (too expensive and bulky) but rather small, cheap, mass-produced hunter-killer drones. Flood an area with them and you could zone out human infantry, without causing the massive damage that artillery or rocket strikes do.
- decafninja 5y agoI am certainly no expert in warfare nor AI, but wouldn't robot tanks (or at least semi-autonomously remotely operated) be much easier and cheaper to do than fighter drones?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- davmonk 5y agoDon't they have some kind of homing missiles in which they can lock in targets?
- lillecarl 5y agoThis reads like a political advert from the US weapons industry to convince people that 20% of national spending on warfare is perfectly reasonable in peace times. I'm doubtful they're(the F-whatever) technologically superior to our little Swedish beast the "Jas-Gripen"[0]. The US just has more military than anyone they're messing with. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saab_JAS_39_Gripen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saab_JAS_39_Gripen
- thrill 5y ago"This reads like a political advert from the US weapons industry to convince people that 20% of national spending on warfare is perfectly reasonable in peace times." Because you go to war with what you have, which has long lead times to design and build and position and train and maintain and employ and resupply.
- lillecarl 5y agoYou're not wrong and it's not all bad. There are so very many useful technological advances though that spending. It still reads like an ad to me, which is weird when it's BBC
- zoomablemind 5y agoAir combat would logically take place when air superiority is contested. If there's no contest (as one side is overwhelmingly superior), then the strategy would rather shift to ground-based anti-aircraft defense. It seems that during active conflicts the main job of air forces remains focused on causing lots of damage on the ground rather than sweeping the skies clear. Just as in old bi-plane days, drive by and dump hand grenades into tranches from above... On the other hand, in peace time, sweeping skies is the main job. I think each successful intercept of enemy craft or in-air detection should be counted as a kill-surrogate. Sure there are plenty of aces on current duty by this count in Northern Europe airforces and in Alaska/Arctic zones, where intercepts of Russia's warring air-cosmic-force activities have dramatically increased in frequency recently. I remember watching some newscast about a politician meeting at an airbase somewhere in Lithuania, with a NATO fighter jet as a background; the in-progress meeting suddenly had to be cancelled, as we could see pilots all dressed up running to the jet to scramble it for an intercept alert. Here it is: https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/41459/presidential-presser-cut-short-after-typhoon-jets-have-to-scramble-to-intercept-russian-planes https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/41459/presidential-pre...
- simonblack 5y agoOnly "at the moment". In my opinion, we are about to have another 'big one' within the next 5-10 years. When that happens, people will be saying "Why are there so many air combat kills?"