4 ms·
It's entertaining watching the Lock Picking Lawyer's videos. He's very good. And far too many locks are embarrassingly bad. Lockpicking ought to be exponential
by Animats 5y ago
It's entertaining watching the Lock Picking Lawyer's videos. He's very good. And far too many locks are embarrassingly bad.
Lockpicking ought to be exponentially hard. You should have to try all the pin position combinations. Something like 5^6 for a 6-pin cylinder. But is in practice, it's not much worse than linear. You can tell when you're making forward progress. That's considered a total fail in a cryptographic system, but is accepted in the keyed lock industry.
The guy with the Stuff Made Here videos did make a lock that is not supposed to let you know if you're making progress. That makes picking exponentially hard again. The info the key provides is recorded mechanically, and then, as you turn the key, that info is later tested with the cylinder in a position that blocks access to the mechanism. That isolation between "read key" and "test key data" is what makes it work. He has an elegant, reasonably compact design, although it turned out to have other vulnerabilities. If you were willing to have a big box of a lock inside or behind the door, like many 19th century and earlier locks, this would be much easier to build.
As locks wear, they become easier and easier to pick. Heavily worn pin-tumbler locks can be opened by almost anything that randomly moves the pins up and down while you apply some tension. Rakes, vibrators, etc.
Many electronic locks are vulnerable due to putting the electronics that makes the decision to open on the outside, where it can be tampered with. You'd think the outside would just have a keypad or sensor, with all the good stuff behind the door, but all too often, no. Also, most electronic locks come with a mechanical backup lock, usually one that's not very good.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hvidgaard 5y agoFor the majority of applications, locks are for "keeping honest people honest". With the right tools most locks take seconds to circumvent, think breaking a window, cutting the steel, drilling out the lock. For situations where it actually matters, professionals know to secure elsewhere before the actual lock is considered.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoI mean, ideally you have a breaking break-in so that you have evidence for the insurance that you have, in fact, been broken into. Best to have a lock that is easier to break than to pick IMO. But yeah, the base premise is that it should avoid crimes of opportunity. Like the steel cables to lock laptops and screens to tables; they won't stand up for a pair of sturdy snips, but they can't be snatched up quickly.
- buran77 5y agoFor people willing to commit insurance fraud putting a few scratches on the lock and door to make it look legit isn't really that much of an effort. Are insurance companies actually conditioning their conclusion based on this kind of evidence? The real value of a lock that's hard to pick is that it forces the burglar to carry more tools and use noisier, time consuming methods. All of this makes the break-in far more obvious and detectable much faster by neighbors, or anyone really, even the owner. And you want to make the job harder and riskier for the burglar so the bar is higher for how willing they must be to go through with the job. Most burglaries are "blind" ones, meaning the burglars have a reasonably good idea of the job's value and difficulty level. So if you have a lot of valuables you have to do your darnedest to raise the job's difficulty: make the break in take time, be noisy, and generally draw attention, or forcing the robbers to leave a lot of evidence behind.
- hvidgaard 5y agoNot the comment you replied to, but the parent comment. I agree with what you said, but I wanted to put in the context of what I wrote. Unless your windows and doors have actual anti burglar features, the lock doesn't matter at all. A large screwdriver is often enough to force a window open and a pry bar will make short work of a door. Not until those have been properly secured does the lock matter. And according to some insurance companies in Denmark, thieves does not pick locks anyway. They use a method of force.
- Pinegulf 5y agoI'm no lockpicker, but fan of the LPL. To me very simple solution would be to have 2x keys requiring to be turned simultaneously. Since picking requires tension and probing no human should be able to pick two spots at the same time. Then again, as noob I suspect there may be very simple reason why this isn't implemented.
- Gigachad 5y agoLPL had a lock like that and he still managed to pick it.
- mulmen 5y agoI think you'll like this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dd-ZIIcgzPI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dd-ZIIcgzPI.
- skinkestek 5y agoI'd note that for a motorcycle disc brake I wouldn't complain about this. If it takes a lockpicking artist more than a minute to pick it while being able to move it around in three dimensions it would take so time on the street too.
- mulmen 5y agoTotally. I don’t think LPL really evaluates the rest of the lock either. How is the drill protection? How does it hold up to an angle grinder?
- skinkestek 5y agoI think he sometimes cut the cord on some devices just to prove that that is even simpler. Or is that someone else?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoI mean... the alternative is to just drill/break the lock, or break down the door. The only added benefit to lockpicking is, that it's harder for the owner to notice that the lock was picked/door opened, but if your plan is to steal an xbox, there are much easier and more efficient (...and destructive) way to do it.
- Gigachad 5y agoThere is no point making a lock more secure. No one actually picks locks other than for fun. They just cut them or hit them with a hammer. That custom design lock shows a lot about why we don’t have ultra secure locks as it takes an insane design with huge numbers of moving parts which aren’t so reliable and extremely expensive to produce.
- joshgrib 5y agoOne interesting case of "locks" getting less secure is for bank bags. On one of the recent LockPickingLawyer videos he talks about how these bags are easy to cut through but that's not usually an issue because they're mainly designed to be tamper-evident. Using a real lock is more of a risk so many banks are switching to an adhesive seal instead of a zipper-lock.
- jmnicolas 5y agoI have no proof but I suspect the LPL to practice the lock before recording the video so it looks like effortless.
- JaumeGreen 5y agoIn some I'm sure he does, but there are some videos of him receiving a sealed package and opening the package (and the lock inside) in a single take. Like this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NSuaUok-wTY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NSuaUok-wTY
- jmnicolas 5y agoWho's to tell he didn't send the package to himself? I'm probably too cynic... I find it odd he hasn't ever found a lock that would defeat him (I didn't watch all his videos though).
- waste_monk 5y agoIf you have sustained access to any lock (and have the skills/tooling) it's only a matter of time. It will only slow down a determined attacker. It's entirely plausible there is no lock that could defeat him. That said, a good security system will have multiple (nested) zones and multiple controls to defeat in each zone - picking a lock by itself should not be enough to gain access, and you should not be able to get to the lock to begin with without being spotted or setting off alarms and triggering a police response.