3 ms·
It is astonishing to me that someone would want to use Windows for something HPC related. I'm not generally a Windows hater (actually I am, but I see that there
by bee_rider 5y ago
It is astonishing to me that someone would want to use Windows for something HPC related. I'm not generally a Windows hater (actually I am, but I see that there are legitimate business reasons to use it), but the HPC ecosystem seems much more Linux-friendly.
- ahelwer 5y agoIt is, but there are a lot of applications that people like to use on Windows PCs (think CAD or data analysis stuff) that have computationally-intensive subroutines. In that company’s case it was GPU-accelerated electromagnetic wave simulations, seismic imaging reconstruction, and CT scan reconstruction. The company developed these libraries and licensed them for use in larger CAD or data analysis software packages.
- aldebran 5y agoThe windows team works closely with hardware makers to support new and upcoming specialized hardware. This enables hardware makers to focus on hardware bring up and not worry about OS support. There are many technologies that work first or better until a certain time on Windows. For example (not necessarily HPC related) SMR drive support.
- bee_rider 5y agoI definitely agree that if I had to get some random device working, Windows is probably a good first OS to try. But since Linux has such a large supercomputer/cluster/cloud presence, the situation is sort of flipped for HPC. At least as far as I've seen -- most numerical codes seem to target the Unix-verse first, and the only weird drivers you need are the GPU drivers (actually I haven't tried much GPGPU out, but I believe the Linux NVIDIA GPGPU drivers aren't the same horrorshow that their desktop counterparts are).
- pjmlp 5y agoSpeaking for the time I used to be at CERN, while the cluster is fully UNIX based, there is a big crowd of researchers running visualisation software, and other research related work on Windows e.g. Matlab/Tableau/Excel, and nowadays I assume macOS as well (it was early days for it 20 years ago).
- bee_rider 5y agoI was thinking more of the number crunching bits, rather than visualization, since the original issue was around performance. But I guess visualization can be computationally cruncy too.
- jiggawatts 5y agoDoes Linux have any HDR support? I looked into recently and the answer seemed to be a firm “no”.
- bee_rider 5y agoHPC=high performance compute. I'm not sure that HDR would come up there. Maybe you are thinking of HTPC (home theater personal computer)? I actually was just looking this up, quite randomly. I think it is actually a soft no, in the sense that support is essentially non-existent now, but it is being worked on. It appears to be an annoying situation where HDCP (high definition content protect, I think) content has some sort of encryption baked in that requires proprietary driver/hardware support. Since the main use case for HDR is watching movies, and we can't do that without the proprietary stuff, there's not a ton of incremental value for the community to get by working on it. But Intel, Nvidia, AMD, and Red Hat are all working on it. https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=Red-Hat-Hiring-For-Linux-HDR https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=Red-Hat-... Also this recent version of libreelec https://libreelec.tv/2021/11/03/libreelec-matrix-10-0-1/ https://libreelec.tv/2021/11/03/libreelec-matrix-10-0-1/ advertises that they can process (decode?) 4k, 10 bit video, on a raspberry pi 4, but they apparently only 8 bit output is actually available. Not sure if this is a hardware or software limitation. Anyway, the pieces are maybe coming together, just very slowly.