3 ms·
I don't think what he did was particularly good but I think he was entitled to do it. And the blame falls on the system we have which relies on random people to
by Gigachad 5y ago
I don't think what he did was particularly good but I think he was entitled to do it. And the blame falls on the system we have which relies on random people to do work for free with no contract or obligation.
It's like if a business delivered packages by asking some random homeless person on the street to walk it to its destination. And then one day the person just chucks your package in the river instead of delivering it. It's amazing that the company got so much value out of a free service for so long rather than shocking that it eventually didn't work.
- balls187 5y ago> And then one day the person just chucks your package in the river instead of delivering it. That analogy makes little sense. In my county, what you described is malicious mischief, and is a crime. A homeless person is not entitled to act in such a manner.
- bee_rider 5y agoMost of the companies that got hit by this (and any paying attention) will probably just change their deployment strategy to slightly slow down their updates. I guess this is equivalent to... I dunno, checking if the random homeless person had at least made one successful delivery? Except the analogy breaks down because code doesn't randomly begin to pick up different behaviors without any intervention (Well, hopefully!).
- WarChortle 5y agoOpen source works because we can trust authors to not maliciously harm other people. If it was a bug that's one thing it happens, you move on. But when you purposely do something that you know will cause harm to people that is where I draw the line. Your analogy isn't even close. No one forced him to write faker.js. He chose to do it and he chose to make it open source under a license allowing people to use it. He also chose to maintain it and help people with issues. If he didn't want to maintain it anymore, It is his right to stop. No company could force him to continue. But he nor anyone is not entitled to add malicious code. Full stop that is where I draw the line. I can't believe anyone is defending that.
- Gigachad 5y agoHe chose to put a package online. He didn't sign any contract stating the package would meet some kind of quality obligations. He had no obligation to do anything. Yes, it is particularly shitty to intentionally screw it up. But the system that put so much value on something not happening without any safeguards or obligations is the real problem. The move fast and break things attitude of web development is the cause. A single rogue dev is just an example of the worst happening. In the future I imagine we will have package managers which do not give random individuals so much power. And we will rely on packages from trusted names, Google for example has a very very low risk of sabotaging a package compared to a no name individual. If companies had paid for this package, they could take legal action against the author. But they paid nothing and had no assurances of anything other than a vague hope it would continue to work.
- butlerm 5y agoHe did something much worse than break a contract, he committed a crime that he could probably be prosecuted for. He did the whole thing with malice aforethought. It looks like fraud at the very minimum - he released a version with the intent to deceive, victims relied on his deception, and they suffered damages as a consequence.
- torstenvl 5y agoFraud requires that he used deception (I don't see any evidence that he did) to obtain something of value (again, I don't see it). The code was open source. The code was published under a new major version number. The code had a descriptive change log that definitely didn't seem congruent with earlier versions. And he wasn't getting paid for it. What thing of value did Marak Squires defraud people of? I get the sense that people are reacting with extreme hyperbole in their accusations, out of anger that he did something assholish. Serious question: how is this different from 1Password publishing an upgrade that removes the ability to use standalone vaults in the iOS Safari extension? At the end of the day, Marak published an update, knowing some people would update the software automatically due to their own workflows, and the update had negative effects on the users. Companies do this all the time and nobody accuses them of installing a "Trojan Horse" or committing a felony. How did it come to this? Where HN, a place that is supposed to be genuine and curious, believes an act should be acquiesced to or branded a felony based on the individual's personality? Because that seems to be the consensus here and I find it disturbing.
- EMM_386 5y ago> I don't think what he did was particularly good but I think he was entitled to do it. And the blame falls on the system we have which relies on random people to do work for free with no contract or obligation. Utter nonsense. You don't put out code under open-source MIT and then want to take it back when you realize other people are using it exactly as you instructed them to use it, which in this case is "anyway they please". You have to think about this stuff before hand if you want to be compensated if it "takes off", there are other licenses you could use.
- Gigachad 5y agoThe MIT license doesn't prevent you from doing this. If someone cloned the repo, they could continue doing whatever they wanted with it, but the owner is entitled to put up whatever new code they want on their repo.
- EMM_386 5y agoThis is technically true. If he wants to act like spoiled brat and put malware in his own code, he can under MIT (he can do whatever he wants, just like anyone else can do with it).