3 ms·
I witnessed the 2020 protests firsthand and saw no looting or riotous behavior; only marching. Commercial theft seems to have been, overwhelmingly, performed by
by woodruffw 5y ago
I witnessed the 2020 protests firsthand and saw no looting or riotous behavior; only marching. Commercial theft seems to have been, overwhelmingly, performed by opportunists and not the protesters themselves, and only one actual property fire was recorded[1].
This is in direct contrast to the efficient cause of the riots during January 6th, which was political and not opportunistic in nature. Attempting to discharge the responsibility of those involved in the latter by appealing to the former is distasteful, to say the least.
[1]: https://citylimits.org/2020/06/09/how-widespread-was-violence-on-new-yorks-nights-of-unrest/ https://citylimits.org/2020/06/09/how-widespread-was-violenc...
- ui4jd73bdj 5y agoTo me the comparison is very accurate. On both occasions there were mostly peaceful protests and some opportunist. The fact that you call one a protest and another a riot is quite telling of your bias.
- woodruffw 5y agoThe key observation is that the NY protests had two discrete groups: protestors, and opportunists. There was no such distinction during J6: the opportunists who did storm the Capitol and menace our legislative branch started as protestors, and promoted themselves to riotous behavior when the opportunity presented itself.
- zepto 5y ago> I witnessed the 2020 protests firsthand and saw no looting or riotous behavior; No, you witnessed a tiny portion of the protests. I personally know of business owners whose businesses were looted, literally just local store owners.
- woodruffw 5y agoI am not denying that stores were looted, or excusing looting. Read the comment carefully: the distinction is between protesters and opportunists, with the latter not being protestors. There is no evidence that protestors individually or collectively engaged in looting.
- Anon1096 5y agoAre you going to make the same distinction for all the peaceful protesters on January 6th who never entered the Capitol? Because if not I don't really see a difference.
- woodruffw 5y agoActually, I do make that distinction, and I think most people do as well. I'm not particularly enthused about the initial protest, but I would not characterize the protestors who did not enter the Capitol (and did not encourage others to do so) as "rioters."
- gumby 5y agoI haven’t heard of any investigation, much less charges leveled, of people who protested but did not enter the Capitol. People who might know of / ultimately be charged with incitement have been subpoenaed, but again, I don’t know of any charges. Anyone pressing such charges will have to show a clear line between first amendment speech and not, so they are going to be careful not to waste their time.
- happytoexplain 5y agoI and all my personal friends make that distinction about both sets of events. Regardless - reading a thoughtful, honest post that you happen to disagree with on some ideological level, and projecting your internal image of a hypocritical political enemy onto them by extrapolating to things they didn't say, is one of the most common forms of conversation poison.
- zepto 5y ago> projecting your internal image of a hypocritical political enemy onto them by extrapolating to things they didn't say, is one of the most common forms of conversation poison. Can you explain how they did this?
- zepto 5y ago> I witnessed the 2020 protests firsthand and saw no looting or riotous behavior; If that isn’t meant to imply there wasn’t any looting, then why did you add it? The rest of what you said is just about definitions and is irrelevant to the facts of what happened. “There is no evidence that protesters engaged in looting” That’s because you use a different name for the people who did. You have no way to be certain nobody who looted wasn’t also there to protest, so the labelling doesn’t mean anything. In aggregate the protests unquestionably led to looting that wouldn’t otherwise have happened. The fact that not all protesters were looters is irrelevant. The looting was part of the protesting, even if not all protesters supported it.
- eric_b 5y agoWell I can assure you the protesters in Minneapolis were violent, destructive, and I personally saw hundreds of protesters looting stores, breaking ATMs, smashing windows etc. etc. Hell, the protesters even burned down the police precinct. The riots in Minneapolis were worse by every metric than Jan 6. And in some cases orders of magnitude (cost of damage, for one). And I'll tell you what else - a lot more people are going to jail for the Jan 6 riots than the Minneapolis ones.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoNot that there is a reason to compare the two, but a mob of people going after the elected leaders of a democratic country, especially during election procedures, has far more implications and ramifications on a country than looting.
- ryan93 5y agoIts actually much worse to unleash violence on poor communities and immigrant business owners.
- eric_b 5y ago
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI would have said the same thing if non Trumpers stormed the building containing a country’s political leaders performing election procedures to certify the country’s new leaders.
- happytoexplain 5y agoThe social/political affiliations of the people involved is not the only variable by a long shot.
- woodruffw 5y agoAt least 85 people have been charged with carrying or using a weapon during the riot[1]. It seems like a large number were knives and other blades which, while not as eye-popping as carrying a rifle into the Capitol, are just as illegal. [1]: https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/zoetillman/capitol-riot-weapons-charges https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/zoetillman/capitol-riot...