3 ms·
> There is no such thing as a legitimate or illegitimate religious belief, assuming there is separation of church and state. I don't understand the conjunction
by woodruffw 5y ago
> There is no such thing as a legitimate or illegitimate religious belief, assuming there is separation of church and state.
I don't understand the conjunction you're creating between these. The separation of church and state protects the state's independence and autonomy from the church, not vice versa. The state is under no particular obligation to protect or enshrine as religious any ridiculous thing you can dream up.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> The state is under no particular obligation to protect or enshrine as religious any ridiculous thing you can dream up. Exactly, which is why being Christian/Jewish/Muslim/Hindu/lotsofpulp’s personal beliefs cannot be a criteria for not abiding by a government mandate. If someone else gets an exemption from government mandate because of their beliefs, then so should I, regardless of how old that belief is.
- woodruffw 5y agoTo be clear: I individually lean heavily towards the "nobody gets a religious exemption" side of things. But no, I don't think there's a reasonable normative connection there. The federal government has (historically) largely delegated vaccination policies and their enforcement to the states, which in turn largely recognize their own right to perform "legitimacy" or "good faith" tests for religious exemptions. The rules for those tests vary widely by state, but among the more common ones are (1) evidence that the individual's views are shared by their broader faith and not a product of individual exegesis, (2) evidence that the individual's request is long-standing (i.e., not merely a product of political winds), and (3) evidence that the individual doesn't belong to a religion expressly for the purpose of acquiring an exemption. None of that seems particularly unreasonable on face value to me, nor is it threatened by or threatening to the US's otherwise extremely strong religious protections.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoEverything in your last paragraph is unreasonable to me. None of those reasons is any business of the government.
- salawat 5y agoYou are incorrect. In fact, religious freedom was originally rooted in protecting religious minorities from State mandated religions. If you look at early American history, many made the original immigration to escape religious prosecution by their former state's religion. The Anglican Church being an example. Religious freedom/separation of church and State were both intended to synergize. You are free to pursue whatever object of worship you please, and the State may not pick and choose anyone's particular target of worship over anyone else's, or force any aspects thereof upon anyone else. Correspondingly, it also keeps political heavyweights (say the Pope) out of the picture as far as lawmaking goes without going through the proper channels (i.e. getting the populace on board enough for legislators to champion the cause). Your understanding of separation of church and State actually has a degenerate aspect to it, in that it basically makes secularism the State religion. Which infringes on religious freedom if the State is free to ignore your religious tenets. The Constitution is a byproduct of getting a large number of the most brilliant minds that could be mustered at the time all in the same room, writing up something to act as a foundation for an entire nascent nation; an undertaking that all present would be willing to be bound by it, and all understanding they'd have to head home and get buy I. From everyone else to ratify it. I'd caution against underestimating the rigor of the shaking out this language was put through in the drafting. Such a work of drafting is... astounding, to be honest, given the difficulty we all seem to have doing the same thing with just laws nowadays.