3 ms·
> It will dissuade people who don't hold legitimate religious beliefs forbidding vaccination (there are substantially zero of them) from using religious exempti
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
> It will dissuade people who don't hold legitimate religious beliefs forbidding vaccination (there are substantially zero of them) from using religious exemptions.
There is no such thing as a legitimate or illegitimate religious belief, assuming there is separation of church and state.
If I want to make up a religion (aka a set of assumptions) this second that contradict societal mandates, then my set of assumptions are just as valid as anyone else’s assumptions, whether they be orthodox Jewish, or jehovah, or whatever the hell people claim to be.
But that is why there never should have been any non medical exemptions in the first place.
- arcticbull 5y agoI suspect you should let Charles Manson's defense team know.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoHow is that relevant? Not murdering people is a societal mandate.
- arcticbull 5y agoNot murdering people by spreading disease is a societal mandate too, in my opinion. People who spread deadly STDs like AIDS can be held liable for attempted murder. It seems we've already decided as a society that knowingly spreading deadly disease is a kind of violence. It doesn't extend here to the same degree because it's obviously much less deadly (and so much is circulating, proving who gave it to you is all but impossible) - however I think the premise holds.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI am confused what you are referring to. I am talking about how people should forced to vaccinate (unless medical exemption) or not forced at all to vaccinate. Letting “religious” people off the hook is nonsensical and contrary to the principles of separation of church and state.
- arcticbull 5y agoOh, I'm so sorry, I think we were just talking past eachother. You and I agree.
- woodruffw 5y ago> There is no such thing as a legitimate or illegitimate religious belief, assuming there is separation of church and state. I don't understand the conjunction you're creating between these. The separation of church and state protects the state's independence and autonomy from the church, not vice versa. The state is under no particular obligation to protect or enshrine as religious any ridiculous thing you can dream up.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> The state is under no particular obligation to protect or enshrine as religious any ridiculous thing you can dream up. Exactly, which is why being Christian/Jewish/Muslim/Hindu/lotsofpulp’s personal beliefs cannot be a criteria for not abiding by a government mandate. If someone else gets an exemption from government mandate because of their beliefs, then so should I, regardless of how old that belief is.
- woodruffw 5y agoTo be clear: I individually lean heavily towards the "nobody gets a religious exemption" side of things. But no, I don't think there's a reasonable normative connection there. The federal government has (historically) largely delegated vaccination policies and their enforcement to the states, which in turn largely recognize their own right to perform "legitimacy" or "good faith" tests for religious exemptions. The rules for those tests vary widely by state, but among the more common ones are (1) evidence that the individual's views are shared by their broader faith and not a product of individual exegesis, (2) evidence that the individual's request is long-standing (i.e., not merely a product of political winds), and (3) evidence that the individual doesn't belong to a religion expressly for the purpose of acquiring an exemption. None of that seems particularly unreasonable on face value to me, nor is it threatened by or threatening to the US's otherwise extremely strong religious protections.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoEverything in your last paragraph is unreasonable to me. None of those reasons is any business of the government.