3 ms·
How about blacklisting Gmail? They're a major source of spam.
by Animats 5y ago
How about blacklisting Gmail? They're a major source of spam.
- blibble 5y agorepo seems to be owned by a google employee
- martenson 5y agoI started the repo and have nothing to do with Google.
- commoner 5y agoThere are 2 members in the disposable-email-domains organization on GitHub.[1] You (martenson) are one of them. The other member (di), who is a "core maintainer" of the project according to the README changelog,[2] is also a member of the Google organization on GitHub.[3] di describes himself as part of the "@google open source security team"[3] and the website linked from his profile says that he is "a Developer Advocate at Google".[4] [1] https://github.com/orgs/disposable-email-domains/people https://github.com/orgs/disposable-email-domains/people [2] https://github.com/disposable-email-domains/disposable-email-domains/tree/6354e34bd18e6b2881e381523e40ce2e6e5a7c1c#changelog https://github.com/disposable-email-domains/disposable-email... [3] https://github.com/di https://github.com/di [4] https://dustingram.com/ https://dustingram.com/
- martenson 5y agoThanks for summing it up. All of this is correct afaik. What I wanted to respond to was the implication that Google is somehow part of this. It is not. This project started before Dustin joined Google open source and was already couple of years old when Dustin himself joined.
- johnklos 5y agoThis is not outside of the realm of possible. Google does nothing to stop spammers, makes up their own non-public rules and doesn't communicate with the Internet community, so Gmail addresses are already on shaky grounds. For instance, for starters, go search through all of your email for any email sent from Google servers where the "Reply to:" doesn't match the "Mail from:", and tell me if there are any legitimate instances. We could all benefit by starting to reject all Google sourced email with a different "Reply to:". What we really need is a blocklist / allowlist system which tracks the millions of Gmail email addresses. Has it never been seen before? Reject it with a message telling them to go sign up for the allowlist. Has it been around for a while? Allow it. Google can't be asked to keep their own spam in check. We have to force it on them.
- AnonC 5y ago> johnklos 8 minutes ago | parent | next [–] This is not outside of the realm of possible. Google does nothing to stop spammers, makes up their own non-public rules and doesn't communicate with the Internet community, so Gmail addresses are already on shaky grounds. For instance, for starters, go search through all of your email for any email sent from Google servers where the "Reply to:" doesn't match the "Mail from:", and tell me if there are any legitimate instances. Why is this scenario a red flag in all instances? Mailing lists, including Google Groups, may have settings that set the Reply To to be different from the Mail From.
- schleck8 5y agoIt's really difficult creating a fake google account nowadays
- 0xC0ncord 5y agoAs someone who gets spam from various Gmail accounts on the daily I'm not inclined to believe it's that difficult.
- Nextgrid 5y agoIt's only difficult for those who want to commit the atrocious crime of having privacy. Lesser evil criminals such as spammers already have a supply chain of phone numbers, residential IP addresses, etc that can be used to work around the restrictions.
- iqanq 5y agoI've created several ones over the course of months without any issue. I wasn't even asked for a phone number. Of course if you do it constantly or from third-world IP addresses, I understand they refuse your attempts.
- Avamander 5y ago> For instance, for starters, go search through all of your email for any email sent from Google servers where the "Reply to:" doesn't match the "Mail from:", and tell me if there are any legitimate instances. We could all benefit by starting to reject all Google sourced email with a different "Reply to:". Yes. Very common. Sorry but you have a very limited view of realistic mail traffic.
- mdasen 5y agoThe issue with blocking Gmail is that Gmail is a lot of people's only email. This list is a list of domains people use for addresses that definitively aren't their primary email address (since they are disposable/temporary/forwarding addresses). While Gmail might be a major source of SPAM, they're also the email service most people legitimately use. If you block dummy-address@my-email-relay.tld, someone might be annoyed, but can sign up with their non-proxied address. If you block Gmail, the person can't just use their "real" address. You're forcing them to create a different email address to use your service - and there's no reason to think that new email address will be from a service that better validates their users.
- Animats 5y agoWhile Gmail might be a major source of SPAM, they're also the email service most people legitimately use. That was once true of Yahoo, Myspace, and even AOL.