4 ms·
> Looking at it from the point of view of the segments, segment 1 is used equally by 100 houses, segment 1 is used equally by 99 houses, and so on. It doesn't
by michaelt 5y ago
> Looking at it from the point of view of the segments, segment 1 is used equally by 100 houses, segment 1 is used equally by 99 houses, and so on.
It doesn't matter.
If a dead end street with 100 houses costs $120000 to maintain, those 100 houses must contribute a total of $120000.
You can price that as every house contributing $1200; or as the first house contributing $24 for access to one segment, the second $48 for access to two segments and so on until the 100th house pays $2400.
But no matter how you rearrange things, the houses' contributions must sum to $120,000 meaning the mean contribution must be $1200.
- mnd999 5y agoIndeed, as soon as you get into “I don’t use that so why should I pay for it”, you’re being consumer and not a taxpayer.
- tzs 5y agoDoes your analysis change if it is not a dead end street?
- michaelt 5y agoIf it's not a dead-end street, the idea of charging different houses different amounts makes even less sense, because the resident of the first house might drive past the 100th house just as often as the resident of the 100th house drives past the first house.
- tzs 5y agoBut if it is not a dead end street then there will be through traffic. Why should the people who happen to live next to that street be covering the maintenance costs that are due to that traffic? And why should they get a free ride--no pun intended--for the traffic they cause when they drive outside of their neighborhood? The point I've been trying to implicitly make is that the road system is best viewed as a whole. Neither the benefits one gains from the road system nor the maintenance costs to repair the wear from one's use of the road system are in general related to how much of the road system is in front of one's house, and so the maintenance costs of that segment of the road system are a poor way to estimate what you should be paying in taxes to support the road system.
- rdtwo 5y agoThat’s how shared sewer works in my area. The person on the end pays the most and the person right at the hook up the least.