3 ms·
Often, yes, but sometimes it does happen because they got the most enthusiastic staff (not yet worn down) and attracted the most prepared poor kids with the mos
by acdha 5y ago
Often, yes, but sometimes it does happen because they got the most enthusiastic staff (not yet worn down) and attracted the most prepared poor kids with the most motivated parents (the ones who’ll take a chance on a new school pledging higher academic standards).
The one I really wish the United States was better at accounting for is assistance for students with special needs. That hammers public school budgets and also means that those kids are discouraged from trying a new school because that’ll reset their support plan even if the new school offers services.
- dantheman 5y agoIt's very simple, just attach the money to the child and then let the parents determine what school they go to.
- acdha 5y agoThat helps a lot but there are some challenges: e.g. you have therapists at a big school with lots of students and they’re all reasonably fully booked but a small charter needs 15% of a person in three different specialties.
- sokoloff 5y agoOr worse, the charter school interview and disciplinary practices ensure that these kids are not admitted or are expelled and the small charter school then takes the full payment but needs 0% of a specialist.
- dantheman 5y agoThe schools, can share a specialist on different days of the week, or if there is an economy of scale then parents will choose it. Sure there may be schools that handle kids with disciplinary issues, like they do today in the public school system.
- kristjansson 5y agoI think the point is that, like a lot of cost problems, a relatively small proportion of users end up accounting for a relatively large share of costs. Just excluding those expensive users (implicitly or explicitly) is a ‘neat’ way to reduce costs and improve outcomes at a particular school. Unfortunately under a funding-follows-kids system that leaves a small population with $X in funding that costs $10X to serve. Maybe grouping all of those users provides enough economy of scale, but that’s not obvious, and sounds a bit like an asylum to boot.
- analog31 5y agoIt's not a market. There's no way for parents to make an informed choice, no way to opt out, no way for the state to opt out of serving as a backup. Also, massively inefficient in terms of minivan miles per pupil per day.