4 ms·
> Take for example the taxes I pay on my home. I pay $260.17 to the city every year in property taxes. I live on a 60 ft wide lot. If you take the $20/ft/year r
by tzs 5y ago
> Take for example the taxes I pay on my home. I pay $260.17 to the city every year in property taxes. I live on a 60 ft wide lot. If you take the $20/ft/year road maintenance metric, cut it in half because I’m just on one side of the street, and then multiply it by the width of my lot you get $600. I would need to contribute $600 a year through my property taxes to just pay for the maintenance of the portion of the street in front of my house.
That is a questionable calculation because the street in front of their house is not just used by them. For example, consider a dead end street with 100 houses on one side and a forest on the other, with each house having the same length of street in front of them. Assume each house uses the street once a day to leave the neighborhood and once a day to return.
The house at the open end of street, call it house 1, uses the segment in front of their house (call it segment 1) 2 times each day.
The house next next to house 1, house 2, uses its segment (segment 2) 2 times each day and it uses segment 1 2 times each day.
In general, house N uses each of segments 1 through N 2 times a day and does not use segments N+1 through 100.
Looking at it from the point of view of the segments, segment 1 is used equally by 100 houses, segment 1 is used equally by 99 houses, and so on.
Figuring fair share by width of lots is even more questionable. A wide but shallow lot and a narrow but deep lot of the same area with similar occupancy aren't going to inherently have different street usage (or different water, sewer, police/fire, or other tax funded service usage).
- acdha 5y agoI’m sure the author would be the first to agree that this isn’t a detailed analysis - they had various comments to that effect - but it doesn’t change the point by anywhere near enough to invalidate it. Most roads are not long dead end streets and especially now that people use navigation apps there’s a lot more traffic on neighborhood roads than there used to be, too. The big problems are low density and how much most cities end up subsidizing non-taxpayers who drive a significant fraction of road demand with only minimal economic contribution. Those subsidies are doubly expensive because they hurt the city and discourage use of more sustainable transportation.
- _dark_matter_ 5y ago"Fair share" is irrelevant, they're now designing an actual taxation policy. Instead they're trying to apportion costs to describe how high the expenses are, based on maintenance costs.
- michaelt 5y ago> Looking at it from the point of view of the segments, segment 1 is used equally by 100 houses, segment 1 is used equally by 99 houses, and so on. It doesn't matter. If a dead end street with 100 houses costs $120000 to maintain, those 100 houses must contribute a total of $120000. You can price that as every house contributing $1200; or as the first house contributing $24 for access to one segment, the second $48 for access to two segments and so on until the 100th house pays $2400. But no matter how you rearrange things, the houses' contributions must sum to $120,000 meaning the mean contribution must be $1200.
- mnd999 5y agoIndeed, as soon as you get into “I don’t use that so why should I pay for it”, you’re being consumer and not a taxpayer.
- tzs 5y agoDoes your analysis change if it is not a dead end street?
- michaelt 5y agoIf it's not a dead-end street, the idea of charging different houses different amounts makes even less sense, because the resident of the first house might drive past the 100th house just as often as the resident of the 100th house drives past the first house.
- tzs 5y agoBut if it is not a dead end street then there will be through traffic. Why should the people who happen to live next to that street be covering the maintenance costs that are due to that traffic? And why should they get a free ride--no pun intended--for the traffic they cause when they drive outside of their neighborhood? The point I've been trying to implicitly make is that the road system is best viewed as a whole. Neither the benefits one gains from the road system nor the maintenance costs to repair the wear from one's use of the road system are in general related to how much of the road system is in front of one's house, and so the maintenance costs of that segment of the road system are a poor way to estimate what you should be paying in taxes to support the road system.
- Ekaros 5y agoNow this leads to question that it only solves problem for that road. What about all the other roads you use? Maybe solution would be to mandate tracking on all traffic? So you would pay what you use, with pedestrians being billed for maintenance of sidewalk, the motorist, heavy traffic and bicyclist the road with some reasonable multiplier.