4 ms·
You do know that atmospheric carbon level estimation is completely orthogonal to carbon dating, yes? Carbon dating is about matching radioactive carbon content
by tsimionescu 5y ago
You do know that atmospheric carbon level estimation is completely orthogonal to carbon dating, yes?
Carbon dating is about matching radioactive carbon contents in organic matter to samples from trees or other known-age organic matter. As such, it has a limit of ~50,000 years ago.
Historic levels of atmospheric CO2 is mainly based on samples of gas trapped in ice sheets, or estimates based on carbon quantity in mineral sediments that would have absorbed atmospheric carbon in their formation. As such, estimates go back to the entire history of the Earth.
Especially for recent history, where we have bubbles of air from those times still trapped in Antarctic ice, I see this is a remarkably direct measurement, the very opposite of a "farcical amount of guesswork". If we're talking about 1 billion years ago, I start to agree with you a little more.
- seniorivn 5y agobut what if there was a time when the ice in Antarctica melt? wouldn't it mean that we don't know when and how long it happened and anything about it's atmospheric contents
- tsimionescu 5y agoThe temperatures required to melt the ice in a short timespan, and then the temperatures required to re-freeze it in a short timespan after that, would leave marks in other places in the world as well. We also know for sure that such extreme events have not happened in recorded history, so at the very least you can trust the method for atmospheric carbon content in the last few thousand years - more than enough to prove man-made as the only explanation of these carbon levels, and to compare for climate effects.