2 ms·
From the Live Science original source: > SpaceX's Starlink satellites alone are involved in about 1,600 close encounters between two spacecraft every week, acc
by zamadatix 5y ago
From the Live Science original source:
> SpaceX's Starlink satellites alone are involved in about 1,600 close encounters between two spacecraft every week, according to Hugh Lewis, the head of the Astronautics Research Group at the University of Southampton, U.K. These encounters include situations when two spacecraft pass within a distance of 0.6 miles (1 kilometer) from each other.
> The current 1,600 close passes include those between two Starlink satellites. Excluding these encounters, Starlink satellites approach other operators’ spacecraft 500 times every week.
> Hesar said that uncertainties in the positions of satellites and pieces of debris are still considerable. In case of operational satellites, the error could be up to 330 feet (100 meters) large. When it comes to a piece of debris, the uncertainty about its exact position might be in the order of a mile or more.
The 1600 number in the title seems to be the number of times a Starlink satellite comes within 1 km of another spacecraft every week while the uncertainties for such craft "could be up to 100 meters". It seems a bit alarmist to transform that into "near-crashes" for the headlines.
> When it comes to a piece of debris, the uncertainty about its exact position might be in the order of a mile or more.
This sounds much more interesting yet no statistics are given on the number of <1 km approaches to debris which makes me think it wasn't as attention grabbing as the other number given. Also lacking is any data on how many orbit changes are done and how that impacts the information given, e.g. is Starlink doing many orbital changes just to a less than 1 km standard proposed in this review? If so why is the 1 km standard treated as such a high risk with the error ranges given, what are the actual risk percentages in these close encounters and should they have really been acted on (or acted on more)?
Overall there is a lot of call for alarm and little sharing of why the data backs it up. It's an interesting topic and concern but seemingly impossible to get solid information on instead of articles just saying we should be concerned.