3 ms·
> it was pretty clear to me that there’s no good reason dealerships exist, as states could also make laws that covered the manufacturer. How would that be the
by HWR_14 5y ago
> it was pretty clear to me that there’s no good reason dealerships exist, as states could also make laws that covered the manufacturer.
How would that be the case? Let's say the manufacturer is in Oregon. Why would laws in California apply to them at all?
- Retric 5y agoBecause presumably their selling cars in California. It’s the same reason online retail needs to collect sales taxes in every state.
- HWR_14 5y agoThere are federal laws and Supreme Court cases specifically and exclusively applying to collecting sales tax that require online retail to do so. There is no legal framework to apply, for example, car lemon laws to those same online retailers. I suppose if you change US law then it might be possible. But if so I would anticipate a major shakeup and secondary effects you wouldn't expect.
- Retric 5y agoThe Supreme Court changed it’s mind independent of any changing federal laws and has removed physical presence from the requirements for the commerce clause. “[e]ach year, the physical presence rule becomes further removed from economic reality” That ruling is therefore not inherently limited to sales taxes and opens the door to lemon laws etc. At least assuming the purchaser is in their home state when the transaction takes place.
- HWR_14 5y agoThe ruling specified that it was a reasonable cost for SD to impose on Wayfair (the third part of a three part test) because of a 2005 federal setting up an interstate sales tax clearing system SD opted into. Meanwhile, all credit card companies operate out of SD to avoid the usury laws limiting interest in the various other states. It's a very narrow opinion. Or, to put it another way, ground your argument in finance laws not in sales tax.
- bfung 5y agoA jurisdiction with sufficient desire (political will) and market power will say “if you want to sell cars in this state, you need to follow my rules.”
- HWR_14 5y agoThat's not a thing they can really do. Look at the banking industry. Every wonder why most credit cards are run out of South Dakota? What if I sell to citizens of California and ship them cars, but we do all the business in Oregon? Sales taxes are a special exception with specific federal laws and Supreme Court rules.