6 ms·
I worked for decades on software for DSLRs. I completely agree that they need to go away, and that new lens tech needs to appear. But I think that we are -jus
by ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago
I worked for decades on software for DSLRs.
I completely agree that they need to go away, and that new lens tech needs to appear.
But I think that we are -just now- starting to get to the point where we can have truly excellent mirrorless cameras that actually can replace (and will surpass) DSLRs.
A lot of it has to do with on-chip computational photography. All the camera companies are coming up with custom image processing chips, and these are what makes the difference.
Lag time needs to be in the single-to-mid-double-digit ms range. I don't remember what the number was, but the company that I worked for, did some research, on what the maximum allowable lag time on a viewfinder could be, and I think it was like 50ms. That means that you need to expose the chip, scan the image from it, do the A/D conversion, demosaic, gamma correct, color correct, denoise, vignette correct, distortion manage, remove chromatic aberration (because cheap lenses), and all the rest of the image processing, then, display it on the screen, continuously, within 50ms per frame, while also not draining the battery. Also, pixel density has a big impact on this performance. More pixels, more milliseconds; more battery drainage.
Not a simple task. You can do tricks like scale down the image early on, and eschew some of the finer image processing tasks, but you still need that viewfinder image to be right on the money, and to the standards of a very picky photographer.
Also sensor physical size has a lot to do with the image quality, bokeh, and what-have-you. A big issue with smartphone cameras (and point-and-shoot cameras), is that small sensors mean that there's little control over DoF (Depth of Field). Apple has introduced artificial bokeh, with their software.
Sensor size, and the length of the optical path, are what really drive lens size. They discuss that, in the article. Hasselblad and Phase One (if they still do that stuff) cameras have these monster sensors. They still need big lenses.
- omegalulw 5y ago> That means that you need to expose the chip, scan the image from it, do the A/D conversion, demosaic, gamma correct, color correct, denoise, vignette correct, distortion manage, remove chromatic aberration (because cheap lenses), Can you explain what's the difference in gamma correction and color correction? New gamma correction uses perceptual mapping right (e.g. Dolby vision) - doesn't that already put you into a standard color space? > then, display it on the screen, continuously, within 50ms per frame That's 20 fps. Don't you need at least 24 to capture cinematic footage?
- realityking 5y ago> That's 20 fps. Don't you need at least 24 to capture cinematic footage? They‘re not talking about fps but latency. From light hitting the sensor to it being emitted again by the viewfinder With all the processing inbetween.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoGamma is basically a logarithmic light correction. It is a digital reflection of an original analog process. Color correction is a much more intricate and subtle thing. Digital cameras have color bias (for example, they tend to like red, a lot, while film liked greens and blues). Color correction makes sure that the colors that come out, can be accurately correlated to the ones that came in. You can also do some cool things, by remapping into different color spaces (a lot of image processing is done by changing the data to a new color space, and playing with the channels). We’re talking the viewfinder, so it is latency. It is also FPS. The viewfinder can be slightly relaxed, but pros will want the viewfinder to be highly representative of the final outcome. Latency is critical, because they use the viewfinder to make the decision when to snap the image, or set the scene. The final output can be slightly more relaxed, with post processing in a buffer. Video makes that a lot more intense. That’s why you have a limit to how many frames you can have in a burst. They get fed into a buffer, for post processing. Another big advance will be true electronic shutters. I’m not sure we’re there yet.
- alexashka 5y ago> Another big advance will be true electronic shutters We're pretty much there. The latest Nikon flagship (Z9) doesn't have a mechanical shutter.
- snapetom 5y agoYeah, I was vehemently anti-mirrorless until maybe just like 6 weeks ago. I tried to use every reason to stick with the latest Canon DSLR, but there are just too many advantages with the mirrorless R5. And a lot of advantages are the computational tech in the cameras that you speak of. The eye tracking and focus is absolutely incredible. Those that claim cellphone cameras will replace dedicated cameras have no idea the advances that are taking place in the cameras. Camera companies are not sitting by idle and waiting for cellphones to make themselves obsolete. They are making incredible strides. With the advantages of the sensor sizes and lens physics, I'm not going to say cellphones will never catch up, but I find it hard to believe they will.
- jhoechtl 5y agoAnd then came the next iPhone. I am by no means an Apple zealot but its astonishing that with every iteration they set new standards.
- snapetom 5y agoMy wife has the latest Pro Max. I have a mini. I also have one of the latest Canon mirrorlesses and pounds and pounds of lenses. Give me my setup any day, but I'm looking at it for what I love to do - wildlife, sports, cityscapes. I don't care about portraits, I don't care about taking picture of food, I don't care about capturing life memories/events. Sure my use case is not what a regular consumer uses a camera for, but a cellphone can't come anywhere close to what I do.
- UltraViolence 5y agoIn my experience even the cheapest (mirrorless) digital snapshot camera runs circles around any mobile phone's. I used to have a cheap Nikon camera and its pictures still stand-out compared to those of even high-end mobile phones (like my Samsung Galaxy S9), especially in low-light or imperfect lighting situations. If you want to take great looking pictures, buy a camera. Don't settle for a mobile phone.
- hammock 5y ago>Apple has introduced artificial bokeh, with their software. Google did it first, on Android phones
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoI believe that. The Pixels have excellent cameras.
- ip26 5y agoEven now it seems like the mirror less bodies are only just reaching parity. They’ll get there, but for now they come with a high price tag and real downsides, while the promised advantages are real but more modest than once thought. An R5 plus RF 2.8 24-70 weighs just about the same as a 5D IV with the same in EF. In-body stabilization was promised to bring 6+ stops, but for supertelephotos I hear it’s delivering around 1 stop.
- ericpauley 5y agoThis is likely a difference between claimed performance on unstabilized lenses and stabilized ones. One additional stop on an already-stabilized lens is quite impressive!
- ip26 5y agoIt’s the march of progress, and I’m glad for every stop I can get. The point is mirrorless is delivering incremental rather than revolutionary benefit. The result is that it’s a gradual succession as the weaknesses are shored up, instead of a game-changing rout.