3 ms·
Ultimately, almost no view is universally heretical since it has to be entirely novel and few people are capable of that. A truly universal idea that is hereti
by renewiltord 5y ago
Ultimately, almost no view is universally heretical since it has to be entirely novel and few people are capable of that.
A truly universal idea that is heretical to start with rapidly gets a cult following because of human novelty impulses and our meme replication ability.
Therefore, most useful heretical ideas likely are/were heretical in some place at some time. The lab leak hypothesis earlier on. Kneeling at a football game. Things like that.
In a temporal sense, interesting heretical ideas suffer from either the Seinfeld isn’t funny effect or from othering different cultures.
I would contend that I have a truly unique heretical idea for the domestic US at this specific time. I hope to build an organ sale marketplace where people sell their own organs at their death. I think this will improve humanity. I know of very few people who agree with me, but none for any reason that stands scrutiny.
- hunterb123 5y agoI'm not quite sure I'd interchange heretical with controversial as you've done here. It doesn't really sound right. You have kneeling at a sports game and talking about a probable lab leak that killed millions in the same list of examples. Personally the word heresy should be reserved for religious contraries or at least when an extreme is needing to be denoted. It was forbidden or taboo to talk about the lab leaky. It was controversial for players to bring politics into sports. I'd view controversial as a lesser as you could still speak dissent. If one view is "heretical", generally the other side wouldn't be "heretical" as well. Which is what you get if you interchange controversial. It was controversial to be against kneeling in football as well. It wasn't controversial to be against the lab leak censor, because you couldn't talk about it at all.
- renewiltord 5y agoControversial and heretical are not interchangeable. I agree. But perhaps this is merely my bubble. My view of this is that kneeling was decried but that it wasn’t controversial to be against kneeling and that at some point it switched and being against kneeling is now the impermissible violation of norms. And my view wasn’t that the lab leak thing was suppressed at all since I heard people talk about the idea frequently. It was just dismissed outright. However, I do agree with you that simple controversy does not imply heresy. Though I do believe that anything truly heretical will result in widespread condemnation. And because of the rapidity of meme replication in humans, it will have parties that adopt it rapidly if it has some value, and will appear as controversy.
- hunterb123 5y agoYeah it seems to be the interpretation of the examples differ between us, not the definition itself. For the kneeling, the norm at the time was to play the game and pledge to the country. Then kneeling came in and it was controversial among a group of people that believed it should stay about the game and viewed kneeling during the pledge as a sign of disrespect. The other side viewed it as controversial to say something against those kneeling under their reasoning of racism. You could say people weren't against kneeling before but it didn't really exist so that wasn't a norm. Similar to trying to prove a negative, it doesn't make sense. For the lab leak, it was banned from all social media sites under and anytime it was mentioned in mainstream news it was shot down as anti-asian racism. It was taboo and banned from discussion. Recently you can talk about it now. It was few months ago that permission was received. There was a big thread here about it. I can find it later today.
- renewiltord 5y agoYeah, I buy that. I suppose that’s what I was trying to talk about when I meant the group. Like I know in the outside world there was this lab leak thing but in the SF startup crowd it was so common. Everyone was suspicious. But that seems to be a pattern. Excepting me (I thought the pandemic was going to be handled well by American bureaucracy), everyone I know adapted well before the government, cancelling trips, taking money out of the market, stuff like that. So it’s possible that in this group, what is heretical is different.
- Zigurd 5y ago"Entirely novel" is a high bar, but that does exclude edgelord rubbish, which is what they think passes for heretical. Taking a knee is mild compared to the precedent of raising a black gloved fist on the podium at the Olympic Games. Still heretical to the nationalist-lite orthodoxy.
- renewiltord 5y agoTrue true. I just really love Kaepernick’s stuff as a recent example because he was ostracized for it and now it’s mainstream. It switched so fast. Also, I agree that the notion of heresy among a lot of these people is just low brow edgelordism. PG is so guilty of this.