6 ms·
Rome: Decline and Fall Pt 1: Words
- msla 5y agoThis always kind of annoys me when people talk about this subject: > In all of these, we will mostly be focused on the western empire (with some gestures at the East), but I’ll note here (and no doubt repeatedly subsequently) that this is because the empire didn’t fall in the East, at least not any time remotely around the fifth century. The continued existence of the Eastern Roman Empire is a free, massive point that the change-and-continuity argument gets to score at the beginning of these debates for free, every time. Is it even possible to talk about the fall of the Western Roman Empire without someone interjecting that the Eastern Roman Empire didn't fall? Is it to be a permanent feature of the discussion, this shift in focus away from the actual topic of discussion? The next time someone talks about the continuity of the Eastern Roman Empire, I'm going to talk about the fall of the Western Roman Empire. Or maybe the fall of the Yuan Dynasty, just for variety.
- jcranmer 5y ago> Is it even possible to talk about the fall of the Western Roman Empire without someone interjecting that the Eastern Roman Empire didn't fall? No. It would be like discussing quantum mechanics without mentioning wave-particle duality--you're missing a key part of the story. If you're legitimately interested in understanding why Late Antiquity played out the way it did, your hypotheses have to come up with a plausible explanation for why the trajectories of the Western and Eastern Roman Empire diverged as much as they did.
- cco 5y ago> No. It would be like discussing quantum mechanics without mentioning wave-particle duality--you're missing a key part of the story. imo I've never been satisfied that the Eastern Roman Empire was sufficiently Roman to actually qualify. Everything I've read and consumed makes me think the Byzantines were as Romans as Romans were Greek, that is to say, they liked to think they were (and possibly claim they were for political reasons). Byzantines spoke Greek, their architecture was not Roman, their military did not behave like Romans, they were Christian, they didn't eat Roman food; if you line up the Roman Republic, or even early Roman Empire, next to the Byzantines and asked an alien whether or not they were the same, they'd say no. They definitely called themselves Romans, they loved to "re-conquer" their old empire in the West etc, but from my perspective there is little to tie the two together as "Roman".
- qwytw 5y agoWell by that standard the 4th or 5th century Roman empire (both east and west) wasn't Roman either. Rome in the 2nd century AD would had probably seemed as alien to a Roman from 3rd century BC as the Roman empire in the 5/6th centuries was to someone from the time of Trajan. Does that make any of the 3 less Roman? By the time the western empire fell being Christianity and Roman identity were inexorably linked and Latin continued to be the official language until the early 6th century. The Byzantine empire itself changed tremendously as well, while by the time of the crusades it was clearly Greek, before the plague of Justinian and the Arab invasions it would be clearly recognized as Roman (aside from religious changes) by anyone from the 3/4 th centuries.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- brokencode 5y agoUh, do you have something against the eastern empire? We shouldn't even mention it when talking about the fall of the western empire? Your point would make sense if the two empires were truly unrelated, but makes no sense when the two were both Roman empires.
- watwut 5y agoNo one interjected anything. Author wanted to talk about both. Author did not changed topic, author set it.
- qwytw 5y agoWell technically the Western Roman Empire did not "fall" it just got merged back into the "eastern" Empire. The collapse of the Roman Empire is just a convenient concept invented by modern historians to serve as an arbitrary line between the ancient times and the middle ages. There were never two Roman Empires, just a single one universal empire ruled by multiple rulers. In 476 it just temporary lost direct control of it's Italian provinces (which it later regained). At the time it was not considered to be some monumental event (e.g. like the Sack of Rome (410) was).
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> 476 it just temporary lost direct control of it's Italian provinces Which also happened several times during the Late Republic, a full half millennium prior.
- rsynnott 5y agoIt's kind of hard to ignore; if your claim is that the Western Empire fell due to A, B and C, then the continued existence of the Eastern Empire, and whether it had A, B or C, surely has to be considered. (In particular, a lot of the simplistic popular views of why the Western Empire fell run into this wall.)
- dash2 5y agoReally interesting. A key part of the cultural argument is about the change in art over the centuries. Of the sculptor of the Tetrarchs, the author says: > The artist is not trying to represent the emperors photographically, but rather trying – and succeeding – at representing the ideal emperors, who fully embody the qualities an emperor should. And: > Often this transition is, I think, misunderstood by students whose knowledge of artwork essentially ‘skips’ Late Antiquity... and leads some to conclude that the fall of Rome made the artists ‘bad.’ There are two problems: the decline here isn’t in quality and moreover the change didn’t happen with the fall of the Roman Empire but quite a bit earlier. How do we know that? One interpretation of the Tetrarchs sculpture vis-a-vis the "verist" sculpture c. 60 BC is that the artist was trying to do something different. Another is that he was just less capable. The earlier artist could capture a realistic portrait of an individual; the later artist couldn't. How do we know that the first interpretation is the right one? The author's argument is that the later artist was still really skilful - as he puts it, "look at those folds!" Yeah, sure, he sculpts way better than I could! But that doesn't seem to prove that he is as skilful as the first artist.
- nolta 5y ago"[L]ook at those folds!" I'm looking at the folds, and they got worse. And take the cover of the Lorsch Gospels: the misshapen fingers, the bulging eyes, the blank expressions -- this is crude, not stylized. You get the sense that art is devolving back to the "archaic smile".
- jcranmer 5y agoThe parallel I would draw in art isn't anime, but the trend in art in the 19th century away from trying to make more photorealistic art. For example, Impressionism. You can look at the works of, say, Claude Monet, and see that the heavy brush strokes and seemingly incomplete nature of his Impressionist paintings aren't because that's only as good as he can do.
- dash2 5y agoI understand the parallel. I accept that sometimes, whether it's Monet or anime, people aren't trying to be realistic. What I want to know is, why should we believe that to be the case here?
- 29athrowaway 5y agoMy theory is that governments are limited by their tecnological advancement, and romans were advanced enough to govern certain number of millions of people. Also, as people raise their standard of living and acquire citizenship, governing them becomes harder as well due to higher expectations.
- booleandilemma 5y agoThat reminds me of the old joke: Why did the Roman Empire collapse? What's the Latin for office automation?
- cco 5y agoA cursory Google didn't find me the punchline; care to help me get the joke?
- chasil 5y agoI have always heard that currency devaluation was a large factor in the fall of the Western empire, but Professor Devereaux doesn't mention it at all. I also did not realize that Alaric lived within the borders of the Western empire, as an independent king. I can see how that would be problematic.
- jcranmer 5y agoEconomic factors are to come in part III, and currency devaluation would be economic in nature.
- jabl 5y agoI vaguely recall from reading Tainter's book (the bible of collapse porn, amirite?) that currency devaluation was more a consequence rather than a cause. That is, the Roman emperors where trying to save the collapsing house of cards by debasing the currency in order to pay for the expenses of maintaining the empire. Of course, Tainter's whole schtick was that worsening, and eventually negative, marginal returns to increase in complexity is the explanation for why ancient civilizations collapsed, but anyhow, his argument is, at least to a layperson like yours truly, somewhat convincing.
- littlestymaar 5y ago> I have always heard that currency devaluation was a large factor in the fall of the Western empire Interesting, I never heard that before. Out of curiosity, did you learn about it in history class or somewhere else?
- chasil 5y agoI think the first I heard of it was my Western Civilization college course.
- ssl232 5y ago(Not OP) I first read about this in The Bitcoin Standard by Saifedean Ammous, the first 2/3rds of which, incidentally, is a history of (in his view) bad money. There he writes how the value of the gold (aureus) and silver (denarius) coins in circulation then was gradually eroded by clipping and debasing the precious metal content in the years leading up to the collapse and he supposes that this had a significant impact on the collapse of the economy and then the empire itself. He links coin debasement to food shortages, as market prices rise to compensate for debased currency. Price caps set by the Roman government stop food producers from being able to adequately profit from their labour, so food shortages occur, then civil strife and eventually collapse.
- pessimist 5y agoThe writer is far more knowledgeable than me, and it seems he believes there was no major decline related to the fall of Rome, the traditional "Dark Age" story is false, etc. I should take him more seriously since he knows a lot more, but it seems clear that there was a catastrophic fall in science, technology and living standards with the fall of the Western Roman Empire. The effect was felt as far as my ancestral land of South India where there was a massive de-urbanization and fall in trade in the 5th century. I do not understand why it is in fashion to deny this decline, and nothing in this blog makes a compelling case otherwise.
- Sniffnoy 5y ago> The writer is far more knowledgeable than me, and it seems he believes there was no major decline related to the fall of Rome, He doesn't claim that at all. In the intro he explicitly claims that there was such a decline and fall. In the body of this first post of the series, he explores the areas where the case against his claim is strongest. That doesn't mean he's suddenly retracted his claims from the intro.
- hnaccount_rng 5y agoHow do you figure that deurbanization in India is related to something happening in Western Europe? Back then trade was for valuables and valuables only. There simply wasn’t the capacity to transport things for everyday use of the general population. And there is a large discrepancy between quality of life for the elite/aristocracy and quality of life for the general population. I would expect the second and third part to answer your questions. And I’m pretty sure there will be some “these parts declined” components
- smorgusofborg 5y agoSpices, food oils, mined metals and fabric are all valuables that are brought to coastal cities in organized trade causing urbanization. The existence of many of those cities, their bazaar and their mosque is all to do with the transition to Byzantine and then only Ottoman trade. It would hardly be surprising if there are many ex-cities that had better trade connections with the western empire.
- eternalban 5y agoPedantic nit: Should be "symbols" rather than "words".
- thom 5y agoIn case anyone wants to devote more time to this subject, Cambridge University's Institute of Continuing Education have an online course on the fall of the Roman empire starting in February (costing £295): https://www.ice.cam.ac.uk/course/fall-roman-empire-3 https://www.ice.cam.ac.uk/course/fall-roman-empire-3
- known 5y ago
- InfiniteRand 5y agoPeople often think of the "Decline and Fall" of the Roman Empire as separate parts, but I think one thing the author illustrates is the fall of the Western Roman Empire was a continuation of the decline. The shifts in culture, declines in economy, the lack of political stability, started before the Western Roman Empire fell. This muddies the dark ages were not too dark argument because are you comparing the height of Rome to the lowest point of the dark ages, and so on. When historical arguments quickly get stuck in the weeds of where you draw the lines, it's a good sign that the argument is probably beside the point.
- InfiniteRand 5y agoOne thing I think the author doesn't flesh out enough is the impact of having the Germanic foederati who settled in the empire keeping their existing chieftan's rule. This helped create a parallel political structure that could easily fill in the void left by the crumbling Roman political structure, instead of having the Roman Empire split into mini-empires like the Gallic Empire in the 3rd century. Perhaps what might have happened without the parallel Germanic political order can be seen in the Italian city-states, although the history there is very specific so that's just what-if speculation.