6 ms·
There is a legitimate reason to oppose header bidding: it results in higher latency than using traditional ad services. Ads served at lower latency tend to get
by pclmulqdq 5y ago
There is a legitimate reason to oppose header bidding: it results in higher latency than using traditional ad services. Ads served at lower latency tend to get more clicks, and so they have more value. Unfortunately, that means that header bidding results in less money for the website.
- civilized 5y ago...or so Google says, paternalistically. Yet for some reason this technique is used by about two thirds of publishers. I guess they're just throwing their money away? Somehow they fail to realize that Google knows best?
- pclmulqdq 5y agoThere are good reasons to not use Google ads if you are a news site: you are competing with Google for being a news provider. Even if you would make more without header bidding, you might not want to use solutions like Google ads since that means supporting someone who is competing with you. I personally think header bidding is the next good evolution of the ad markets (and the ad market seems to agree), but there is a cost to it.
- civilized 5y agoHow does Google compete with news providers?
- throwaway6977 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_News https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_News
- civilized 5y agoHow is a service presenting links to a publication competing with that publication?
- Kalium 5y agoFor a lot of people, the headlines are all they really want to read plus maybe a snippet of a sentence or two. News outlets that expect to sell those eyeballs lose out and consider this unfair competition from Google. Google, for its part, has been perfectly happy to remove publications from Google News at their request. Or leave entire countries.
- josefx 5y agoBecause that completely replaces the front page of the news site, a page people normally visit just to find out if there are any articles worth reading. I can see how that leads to less ad impressions on the news site itself if people only visit it when they found an interesting article (and just that article) on google news.
- smegger001 5y agoTo be fair most newspaper websites form pages I have seen have been eyebleedingly bad; stuffed to the gills with anti-patterns, obnoxious amounts of ads and some of the worst user interface designs I have seen on the internet. is it any wonder people use google instead of newspapers own sites?
- HWR_14 5y agoI feel like a late loading ad that pops under peoples mouse gets more clicks than any other ad does. So are we sure about your statement that low latency leads to more clicks?
- mulmen 5y ago> Unfortunately, that means that header bidding results in less money for the website. Can they make up the difference in not getting ripped off by Google?
- judge2020 5y agoProbably not, since I doubt the ad network sends that much more of the margin it makes without Google back to the website.
- streptomycin 5y agoYou'd be surprised. Every time I've observed a switch to header bidding, revenue goes up like 50% or so. And I've heard the same from many other people. I don't think I've ever heard someone say it didn't improve revenue. And yes, that increase is after the new middleman takes his typical 20% cut!
- harrisonhope 5y agoYes, this is why many larger media sites opt to use header bidding. The decrease in CTR (click through rate) is offset by increased demand for each ad unit, driving up CPM (effectively the price of the ad). The downside of this for websites is more middlemen extracting away value - but it’s usually still a net gain, otherwise publishers just wouldn’t use header bidding. (I’ve worked in several large media companies and have implemented header bidding solutions for them in the past)
- edgyquant 5y agoCould the latency problem be solved?
- pclmulqdq 5y agoIt's pretty fundamental: header bidding involves an extra hop through the client. It's encouraging that other commenters are saying that they are adopting header bidding despite this.
- markab21 5y agoI'd be surprised if they don't have async mechanisms.
- jefftk 5y agoIt's async, but since it's selecting the ad it still has to run before ad can be shown.
- adtechmadness3 5y agoClient side header bidding requires an HTTP request / response for each bidder, followed by an HTTP request to the primary ad server (very often, Google Ad Manager), that usually runs its own ad selection process (against lime items from direct sales, and programmatic demand sources such as Google Ad Exchange). Server side header bidding offsets the call to each bidder to the server side and it somewhat improves latency, but it still takes some time to complete the auction, and there's still need for an extra HTTP request / response to the header bidding server.