7 ms·
‘Trading is gambling, no doubt about it’ cryptocurrency dealing fuels addiction
- jasfi 5y agoI'm working on an automated crypto trading system. The goal is to prevent serious loses by using rules that should be safer than the way most people trade. I don't want to make something that fuels an addiction, but instead is skill-based. Any opinions on this?
- protoax 5y agoPretty much none of crypto trading can ever be skill-based depending on the time frame. Even in the medium term it’s a random walk.
- jasfi 5y agoThat's the dream of the quant!
- petemcc 5y agoInterested in your thoughts on how most people trade. Also curious what the ruleset will do, along the lines of existing risk management strategies? (Limit % of account per trade and % per day or strategy to a certain level of loss?) If it's automated, I think it probably circumvents the more "addictive" type behaviours as they tend to be more prevalent in scalping or day trading strategies. What sort of timeframes are you targeting?
- jasfi 5y agoFrom what I know it's partially based on what others are saying (e.g. Twitter), partially emotion based (fear/greed/etc), and otherwise based on luck. Some will pick a hyped coin and hope for the best. Risk management will be a big part of it. I was even thinking of enforcing %s to limit risky behavior, but users would probably just leave if I did that. Yes the idea is that automation reduces trades that aren't well thought out. I want to target as many timeframes as possible, but will likely start with 12H and 1D for the MVP. Website with sign-up for the MVP: https://tradecast.one https://tradecast.one
- ffggvv 5y agothe same is happening with robinhood, especially with options. people are betting large sums on options that expire the same day
- tharne 5y agoOptions are terrifying. I don't think retail investors should be allowed to short stocks. Very few people understand the concept of an unlimited downside.
- jedimind 5y agoIt's clearly you who is not understanding how shorting with options works, since the downside is limited and NOT unlimited as you wrongly claim. Buying puts for let's say $500 let's you short a stock, now if the stock moves up, you can lose 100% ( if it doesn't come down within expiry ) but you can't lose a single cent more than that. One way to have unlimited downside is naked shorting.
- crent 5y agoUnless you sell uncovered calls… that gives you unlimited downside risk and limited upside since a stock can theoretically go to infinity. It’s not technically shorting but you are making a bet that the stock will remain the same price or lower.
- che_shirecat 5y ago100%. however, naked or uncovered calls and puts are almost always put past level 4 trading approval. counter to GP's claim, there's no way you can accidentally stumble into trading these.
- ABeeSea 5y agoRobinhood doesn’t support naked positions at all.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dnautics 5y agoWait the guy had an addiction, and the way he lost is money was that he was too busy being obsessed with trading that he lost the ADDRESSES? This makes it seem like cryptocurrency is a better outlet for gambler's addiction than horseracing, anyways.
- bigyellow 5y agoNoooo ... you can't just make money outside of the inflation-driven fiat system! Crypto is BAD because you'll be an ADDICT! How do people still believe this bullshit or pay any mind the "Guardian"? It's clear and obvious propaganda.
- greatpostman 5y agoExactly my thoughts as well
- mygoodaccount 5y agoCryptocurrency trading, stock market trading, sports betting, slots, and opening Pokemon card packs are all functionally "gambling". However, people will generally only use the word for types of gambling they disagree with.
- tharne 5y agoThere's a meaningful difference between casino-style gambling and investing in something like stocks or cryptocurrency. Specifically, in a casino the odds are known and fixed in favor of the house. If I'm playing roulette at the casino and place $1000 on black, I have a less than 50% chance of winning (18/38) due to the two green spaces on the wheel. Over a long enough period of gambling the house will win and I will lose. With stocks or cryptocurrency, things are very different. The odds are not known in advance, nor are they controlled by a specific organization. You can have a situation, particularly with stocks, where value is actually created and there is a net increase in wealth - this is not possible in traditional gambling, which is explicitly zero-sum.
- enricozb 5y agoSurely crypto has always been zero-sum? People put their money into the pot, and then take it out at different times, in proportion equal to when they originally put their money in.
- thebean11 5y agoIt depends on the currency, some have transaction fee mechanisms that pay existing holders, meaning there’s at least some amount of revenue (holders are selling transaction slots to transactors). Holding the currency is essentially a bet that revenue will increase
- lultimouomo 5y agoCrypto seems to be negative sum, due to the large amount of equipment and energy expenses that go into operating the whole infrastructure. (Obviously this is technically true of almost everything, but in case of cryptocurrencies I think the relative operating cost is much higher than, e.g., stocks or bonds or casinos).
- cblconfederate 5y agoNo doubt it has always been gambling, and equally addictive. But that includes all trading, not just crypto
- notch656a 5y agoLife is gambling. Holding fiat is a gamble you won't be inflated to hell.
- greatpostman 5y agoThe government massively depreciated the purchasing power of the dollar, trading is one of the few ways to get ahead. And the secret is it’s not always as hard as the professionals claim, especially when the government is money printing
- protoax 5y agoTrading is gambling for almost everyone. The remaining actors benefit from additional information that is either entirely cost inhibitive or illegal.
- greatpostman 5y agoBelieving this is the biggest trick the finance industry ever pulled. Many people are capable of consistently making money, poker is gambling but some people always win over long enough variance
- protoax 5y agoThis is just nonsensical. Are you familiar with the famous bet made by Buffett that a basket of hedge funds would be outperformed by the market over 10 years? He was right, they were outperformed, so how does it follow that a basket of hedge funds with massive budgets cannot consistently make money trading - but the average person somehow can? Are they intentionally handicapping themselves to "trick" everyone?
- greatpostman 5y agoThis is a brainwashed opinion. I have worked in finance. Comparing investing billions to investing one million is nonsensical
- gumby 5y agoI wonder if clickbait and doomscrolling exploit the same cognitive mechanisms as gambling addiction.
- mgamache 5y agoThis assumes that you have the option of not gambling. However, you are forced to use the roulette table by fiat currencies. How much will USD be worth in 5 years? Who knows. It's less risky than other options, but a sure loser in net worth with inflation. The only way to not lose is to adopt some type of more risky position (AKA gambling).
- LatteLazy 5y agoMeta: The guardian is privately funded. They have neither shareholders nor customers to flatter. So they could do really hard hitting pieces. Long form. Actual investigate journalism. Instead it's all just the equivalent of badly researched reddit comments.