7 ms·
The Medieval Queens Whose Daring, Murderous Reigns Were Quickly Forgotten
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoIt is a cool story. I was unaware of these queens. I suspect that we may hear more, soon enough. This article is probably timed to raise interest in her forthcoming book. I lived in Baltimore for several years. Always good to see a hometown girl make it good, and wish her luck.
- Wolfenstein98k 5y ago
- hluska 5y agoEvery single story?? Why does this upset you so much that you would completely exaggerate the truth? It was one sentence at the end of a minor paragraph in one article, written by a poet. Who cares?
- pessimizer 5y agoHow can you be so triggered about people talking about the things that trigger them that have nothing to do with you? This morning I was watching a 60s comedy about a bunch of ambassadors at an international UN-like meeting. There was one black ambassador from Africa, and every time he said anything, the other ambassadors made jokes about him eating the other people in the room. It's just a joke, but it's just a joke about how the one black person in a room full of white people must be trying to eat them. I can either be sad about that, amused by that, nonplussed or indifferent. The weird thing is how mad you get based on how I feel.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mjburgess 5y agoIn this case the author is talking about the person the article is about. It is relevant that the operatic Brünnhilde is more an object of ridicule, in contrast to the queen on which she's based.
- jevoten 5y agoI haven't seen Der Ring des Nibelungen yet - does the opera really ridicule Brünnhilde, as this article implies?
- okintheory 5y agoGood point, or it would be, if only the world had not shoehorned misogyny into almost every little bit of our history.
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoLet me fix that for you: If only it weren't so easy to find mysogyny in every little bit of our history?
- jdonaldson 5y agoQueens are notable because they had immense power... and knew the score with gender bias and had the means to change minute details of the subjects' lives. However, they rarely changed cultural norms WRT gender. I'm thinking mainly of Cleopatra (and Nefertiti, even though she never held the highest title AFAICT). It may be because there are just bigger problems for leaders to solve.
- bawolff 5y agoI imagine its because cultural norms don't change in a day -it takes generations, and ultimately these people are mortal.
- pjc50 5y agoHow could a patriarchal society that explicitly reserved power and property for men contain misogyny? Historians are baffled.
- okintheory 5y agoThat's what I meant, but I see the phrasing is ambiguous...
- user-the-name 5y ago
- PontifexMinimus 5y ago> Find it in your heart to be angered by injustice, rather than by the reaction against it. Yes, there is injustice in the world. For example, right now there are people in concentration camps being enslaved and forced to do work making goods for big corporations, with the goods then being sold on the shelves of your local supermarket. Or another example: right now there are massive corporations that unfairly make billions of dollars through rent-seeking. Often this involves bribing politicians to get a favourable regulatory environment. (Note that I am not complaining about companies that get rich making thinks people want, but only about one that get rich through rent-seeking). A third example: in the USA the healthcare system costs per capita more than in any other country in the world, yet Americans have worse health -- for example they die earlier -- than in the vast majority of rich countries. This system continues to exist because it serves well the section of the ruling class that owns/runs the healthcare industry, even though many die every year because of it. There are real injustices in the world, real things that could be fixed to make people's lives better. Find it in your heart to care about these things, rather than merely engaging in performative sanctimoniousness about the phrase “It ain’t over till the fat lady sings”. If woke people diverted their energy to finding real solutions to real problems rather than virtue climbing, they'd probably be able to cause significant good in the world. But as I see it their effect is mostly negative.
- igorkraw 5y agoWe can multitask. All of these are bad, but it seems to me, you are wasting energy being angry at this person dealing with her problems of choice instead of fixing the ones you use here as a cludgel. How are is shutting this person up going to help fixing there wrongs?
- PontifexMinimus 5y ago> you are wasting energy being angry at this person dealing with her problems of choice instead of fixing the ones you use here as a cludgel I have in the past spent thousands of hours and thousands of pounds attempting to fix some of these issues. > How are is shutting this person up going to help fixing there wrongs? I don't want to shut them up, I want to redirect their energy to things that are productive.
- andrewclunn 5y agoThe number of people who will share when you appeal to woke ideology + those who will hate share in order to ridicule any such instance = more engagement.
- FooBarBizBazz 5y agoHow else is she supposed to sell Germanic history to the academy? It fits nicely with an observation she made herself: > [Brunhild] appears unnaturally tall and pale in illuminated manuscripts from later in the medieval period; voluptuous and glowing in Renaissance portraits; pensive and windswept in Romantic-era prints. Well, this portrait, made today, says "yasss queen". Anyway, the article is structured as a sandwich, and if you skim past the "bread" at the ends, the "meat" is worth reading.
- toss1 5y agoSo, one factoid, small and relevant (contrasting the fate of the operatic character vs the actual history on which she was bases), so annoys you by highlighting your misogynistic worldview that it is the only thing in the entire article that you find worthy of comment? Why so threatened?
- cafard 5y agoI remember the term as being popularized in the 1970s, in regard to the Washington Bullets' chances of winning the NBA championship. I thought that it was the coach who coined it, but Wikipedia says not. Anyway, Wikipedia traces the expression "The opera ain't over till the fat lady sings" no farther back than the middle 1970s. The Ring Cycle had a fair bit of history by then; and I'm not that confident in the ability of guys in the 1970s sports world to name the soprano roles in opera.
- technothrasher 5y agoThere's a 1976 book titled, "Southern Words and Sayings" that references the phrase as, "Church ain't over until...". This suggests that the phrase predates the 1970s basketball usage, though I don't think there is any actual recorded use of it before the mid 70s.
- RobertMiller 5y ago
- lolinder 5y agoYou may not agree with the line, but it's not shoehorned in, it's what the article was written for. It's literally in the lede: > Over the centuries, Brunhild and Fredegund were dismissed and even parodied. But a new book shows how they outwitted their enemies like few in history
- tshaddox 5y agoHave you seen even one other article mention the origin of that phrase? I haven’t.
- snarkerson 5y ago
- Hokusai 5y agoCleopatra has been similarly dismissed, but in her case as just a beautiful face. It's wonderful to see a more serious approach to history that judges people from their acts instead of personal expectations.
- cafard 5y agoPeter Green gives a very respectful picture of Cleopatra in his Alexander to Actium.
- nopenopenopeno 5y agoI’ll never forgive them for what they did to Hillary. It was her turn!
- Archelaos 5y ago"The jewels flowed in from the east, while the slaves, like Fredegund herself, were shipped from the north in wagon carts, their arms bound by jute rope." Jute is a Mediterranean plant. It seems somewhat implausible that it was used in the north. Does anyone know of any archealogical evidence of jute ropes in the north during the Dark Ages?
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoMaybe the rope was not made from jute, but made by the Jutes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jutes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jutes although then it should be capitalized so that also seems unlikely.
- pjc50 5y agoWhy couldn't it be shipped in the opposite direction?
- karaterobot 5y agoIt could have been. Commenter was asking if anybody knew of archaeological evidence that it was.
- smegsicle 5y ago'here take all this rope- bring it back after wrapping it around a bunch of slaves'
- RobertMiller 5y ago
- labster 5y agoFibers tend not to survive very long in moist climates, so I’d expect direct evidence of jute to be mostly absent.
- paleotrope 5y agoWhy assume it's not just some poetic license on the part of the writer here.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tasha0663 5y ago> First, though, she belts out a poignant aria, giving rise to the expression, “It ain’t over till the fat lady sings.” Her character became yet another way to casually ridicule women’s bodies and their stories. Uhh, actually we're ridiculing over-the-top opera productions that the 17 hour Ring Cycle represents. If anything, we should be glad it is Brunhilde's aria that is remembered as the ending, and that the saying isn't "it's not over until the sexy Rhinemaidens swim away with the ring".
- labster 5y agoIn Toejam & Earl (and the recent remake for PC), there’s a fat opera singer dressed as Brunnhilde. But actually she’s a phat opera singer, and the most powerful character in the game by far. Her soprano shrieks cause enemies around her to pop! immediately. That’s not a bad impression. You always want to encounter her on a level. She doesn’t pop you, only annoying Earthlings who can’t dig funky sounds. So yeah, for a lot of us who grew up with that game, the fat lady singing is an expression of feminine power, with a lady comfortable with her body. So an obvious target for shallow cancellers.