3 ms·
> How about the radical position of letting each state decide for itself? The current state of affairs is that the constitution does not allow the federal gove
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> How about the radical position of letting each state decide for itself?
The current state of affairs is that the constitution does not allow the federal government, or the states, to prohibit abortion, guns, or gay marriage. So the status quo is that this is up to the individual. Leaving it up to the states would be a regression.
- dane-pgp 5y ago
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoNow you're making the argument against "leave it up to the states." Laboratories of democracy work great when different states have different characteristics or preferences. It makes no sense to have a federal minimum wage because a living wage is a vastly different amount of money between New York City and El Paso, Texas. Maybe people in Massachusetts prefer to have high taxes and a lot of government services and people in New Hampshire the opposite. But if something is a right, it's a right everywhere.
- TulliusCicero 5y ago> has their taxes increased to reduce the taxes paid by a gay couple. Are you serious? By this reasoning, previously the gay couple was experiencing higher taxes to reduce the taxes of straight couples.
- dane-pgp 5y agoLike I say, I don't want to have to argue for any particular side in those debates, or to make those positions sound serious if they are not (although I think some people do seriously hold them). My point was that just because something can be labelled "progressive" doesn't mean that everyone supports it (or supports it enough to pay more taxes for it).