3 ms·
The problem with silverlight: The promise: a replacement for AJAX, Flash, etc., JITted code compiled from modern and advanced languages running in the browser,
by InclinedPlane 15y ago
The problem with silverlight:
The promise: a replacement for AJAX, Flash, etc., JITted code compiled from modern and advanced languages running in the browser, sandboxed, safe, fast, with advanced design tools and IDEs usable for easily creating beautiful and usable UIs. In theory a great thing.
The reality: just another Flash competitor, used for pushing video 98% of the time anyway. Why bother if Flash is already everywhere and "good enough"?
- InclinedPlane 15y agoP.S. Also, MS was too scared to use IE to push forward an in-browser silverlight as a thorough AJAX competitor, as google might end up doing with dash.
- jroseattle 15y agoMostly a captive market of Microsoft-oriented devs with invested skills in C#/VB, and an ability to push out a client install package through Windows update. Having developed against both, I found Silverlight development much easier than Flash development. It makes the most sense for enterprise/corporate/internal applications, where end-client availability is much more controlled. But outside the firewall, Flash is certainly good enough.
- frou_dh 15y agoYour quip about these plugins being used 98% for video is spot on. I think Flash has served its purpose and should go away now, but it definitely did a good job of kickstarting decent in-browser video in the 2000s.
- tsotha 15y agoPorn. Is there anything it can't do?
- mikeryan 15y agoI know a lot of folks who used it to stream video mostly just because it supported PlayReady DRM. I'm not saying thats the right reason but thats one reason for choosing it over Flash. Netflix used (uses?) it for their web streaming.
- DrJokepu 15y agoBecause Flash is not good enough. Flash video playback has an incredibly poor performance, especially with h264 or HD videos, even on average machines or Macs. Silverlight video playback is simply a lot smoother. I'm not sure if it's their codecs or somewhere else in their rendering pipeline, but ultimately it doesn't really matter. What matters is that my users can play back the videos on my site smoothly even on their shitty commodity Dell boxes. That being said, I'd love to switch to HTML5. If only all the browsers settled on the same codec.