5 ms·
> So AI is magic No, this is absolutely the wrong takeaway from the article. NN's are not magic, they are completely understandable in terms of how they work a
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
> So AI is magic
No, this is absolutely the wrong takeaway from the article. NN's are not magic, they are completely understandable in terms of how they work and what they do.
However, they do not (easily, if at all) allow the construction of an explanation of why, given input X, they produce output Y. You cannot (easily, if at all) construct a theory of how they generate outputs. So you end up settling for (fairly, or even remarkably suprisingly) accurate predictions, but without the sense that you understand how they are generated, even though you are 100% clear on the mechanism.
That's not magic.
> There are a lot of USEFUL tools on this planet which do not fall under that umbrella, and there have always been. AI is just the latest one we have.
The point of the article, at its heart, is precisely to ask whether these NN-based approaches are in fact science or not. It's not insisting that they are, but pointing out that they are create a gray zone that is qualitatively different from the 3 examples you offer as other non-scientific approaches to understanding. Why? Because they operate in a domain still legitimately filled with much of the language of science, but not much of the technique. That's not true for spiritual practice, traditional medicine or meditation.