3 ms·
> Sticking with on of the examples, we know that proteins fold in somewhat predictable ways, because we do have theories around the "mechanics" there But we we
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
> Sticking with on of the examples, we know that proteins fold in somewhat predictable ways, because we do have theories around the "mechanics" there
But we were broadly unable to leverage those theories and knowledge into a predictive system. AlphaFold largely dropped all that (IIUC), and works much better without it.
(I was once a PhD candidate in protein folding, and left in part because I felt the field was unlikely to make any substantive progress. It didn't, for at least 30 years, until NN-based "modelling" started to replace all approaches up till then)
- dataangel 5y agoWell, but wasn't AlphaFold at least in part trained based on the existing mechanical models? Or was AlphaFold only trained on ground truth imaging of the folding process?
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoIt was trained on experimentally-determined physical structures. Not predicted models based on various folding engines.
- snowwrestler 5y agoThe point is that given a solution to protein folding, we can then compare that solution with current theory and even physically test it. The search space is enormous but individual solutions are physically deterministic. This is a good application of ML since there is an independent “check” on its work. And it’s hard to call it “the end of theory” when theory is still tightly coupled with the system, just at the back end instead of the front end. That is not true of many applications of ML, like Facebook, which simply spit out solutions at scale with no way to independently check them. We should not think the same way about all ML systems; there is a lot more to it than just the neural network.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoHow is theory still involved? You don't use theory to check the predictions AlphaFold makes, you use molecular structure determination (x-ray crystalography, MRI, other techniques). Of course, those involve "theory", but not theories about protein folding.
- RandomLensman 5y agoFor me, theory enables this to actually work in the sense that we know that structures are not random, i.e. there is some way to predict them and it is inherent in the composition (hand waving). If there is no theory linking input and output then predictions could just randomly stop working, for example.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoThis is just simply incorrect. Theory is not involved in this. We know that a given protein will always (more or less) fold into the same configuration every time, generally on their own. We know this by doing experiments in which the protein is denatured (heated to break internal covalent and some ionic bonds, and then left to anneal (cool down), and then inspected at the atomic level for the resulting structure. They always fold back to the same shape. This is an experimental determination, not a theoretical one. Nobody was ever successful at devising any comprehensive theory that explained how they did this, though they of course identified many different elements that are likely involved in some way (hydrophobicity, local charge, possible compactness and many more). But there is (currently) no theory that connects protein amino acid sequence to structure, which is why AlphaFold was such a huge deal. It makes the connection (somehow), without any theory builtin, and without any theory to explain. In fact, there is not even a theory that requires that they always fold into the same shape.
- RandomLensman 5y agoYou are misunderstanding me. There is theory about how atoms etc. interact. We cannot use that to predict shape (at present) but at the same time there is no force etc. missing as far as our current understanding is concerned (at most basic level no physics seem to missing). So predictions seem at least possible or rather are not blocked. On the other hand, trying to use an AI to make predictions which atom of a radioactive element was to decay next would run afoul of current theories.