3 ms·
"I'd rather have everyone fed, clothed, housed and medically taken care of than having a low chance of "winning"." I think this is creating a false dichotomy b
by giantg2 5y ago
"I'd rather have everyone fed, clothed, housed and medically taken care of than having a low chance of "winning"."
I think this is creating a false dichotomy by implying that it's a foregone conclusion that a soup kitchen style of government would be able to support everyone.
"How can I enjoy a steak without thinking about whether or not this animal had a good life? It died so i may eat it, but why did it live in the first place? Just to be eaten?"
First, buy local from small producers. You can see how the animals live.
Are we not born to toil and die? Why should we be born? It seems we serve some minor purpose at best, under the control of some government, and then die thinking that we left some grand legacy simply for having children to continue on.
- mlatu 5y ago> I think this is creating a false dichotomy by implying that it's a foregone conclusion that a soup kitchen style of government would be able to support everyone. uh, soup kitchen style of government? how about no government at all? just to clarify: for me communism is the antiauthoritarian leftism that is in the bottom left of the political compass. top left?: stalinism&maoism, top right?: nazigermany, quarter-to-the-bottom&full-right?: USofA exaggerated? perhaps. > First, buy local from small producers. You can see how the animals live. good point, if you live in an area with local, small producers. I cannot speak for my miserable parents, but I definetly did not have children for them to just toil and die. I just want everyone to have a good time. Distancing ourselfs from eachother by using money to measure the value of every interaction is definetly not The Way for everyone to have a good one.
- giantg2 5y agoBut we understand that life is full of struggle and death, yet we have children. "Distancing ourselfs from eachother by using money to measure the value of every interaction... " That's a choice. One can always volunteer. It seems human nature will always find some way to measure value transfer, or at least determine if someone is worthy of the "free" service. I think we see this in libertarian communities - most people contribute, but freeloaders could be labeled as such.
- mlatu 5y ago> But we understand that life is full of struggle and death, yet we have children. yeah, because life is also full of beauty. As to that choice: Sure, you just don't see many banks in volunteering in letting go of a debtor ;) If I had the time, I would.
- giantg2 5y agoAnd it was the debtor's choice to get involved in those transactions. Many businesses, including banks, make charitable donations.