4 ms·

> they can't inject ads. They totally can, just not at a moments notice. Putting a car ad into a car video-> works. Shoutout to sponsor -> works. Putting the s

> they can't inject ads. They totally can, just not at a moments notice. Putting a car ad into a car video-> works. Shoutout to sponsor -> works. Putting the scam ad of the day -> doesn't work (or needs some effort).

orthoxerox 5y ago
> Putting a car ad into a car video-> works. Shoutout to sponsor -> works. If SponsorBlock is integrated into youtube-dl, then it no longer does.
- bmn__ 5y ago
  The good fork already has it. <https://github.com/yt-dlp/yt-dlp#sponsorblock-options https://github.com/yt-dlp/yt-dlp#sponsorblock-options>
  - matheusmoreira 5y ago
    I didn't know about that! This is awesome!
- dspillett 5y ago
  I draw the line before SponsorBlock though. While they are repetitive and irritating after a while (if I was going to join skillshare I'd have done so some time ago, kindly bugger off, etc.): * They do directly pay the people making the content * That income can't be taken off them by the medium (youtube usually) deciding to demonetize the content * YT isn't even taking a cut, in fact * Those ad placements aren't trying to stalk me around the Internet and storing every tiny bit of information about me they can glean * Sponsorship bit are usually there because they have at least some tentative relevance to the content and the people consuming it, without the need to stalk us as we travel around the Internet At least until such time as the video carries like youtube start inserting ads directly into video streams, then I'll reconsider. I don't block ads to block ads: I block adds as a side effect of blocking stalking behaviours, wasted bandwidth from auto-playing video, 3rd party code on otherwise half-reputable sites trying to access my camera & mic, slowing my devices via poorly optimised animations, pop-ups that may interrupt other app use away from the browser, pop-unders too, battery drain from CPU use when mobile, being forced to interact because I can't just look around or scroll past as the ad is over the content, ... If the stalky inserts start to happen then I'll react by using sponsorblock or similar.

orthoxerox 5y ago

> Putting a car ad into a car video-> works. Shoutout to sponsor -> works. If SponsorBlock is integrated into youtube-dl, then it no longer does.

bmn__ 5y ago
The good fork already has it. <https://github.com/yt-dlp/yt-dlp#sponsorblock-options https://github.com/yt-dlp/yt-dlp#sponsorblock-options>
- matheusmoreira 5y ago
  I didn't know about that! This is awesome!
dspillett 5y ago
I draw the line before SponsorBlock though. While they are repetitive and irritating after a while (if I was going to join skillshare I'd have done so some time ago, kindly bugger off, etc.): * They do directly pay the people making the content * That income can't be taken off them by the medium (youtube usually) deciding to demonetize the content * YT isn't even taking a cut, in fact * Those ad placements aren't trying to stalk me around the Internet and storing every tiny bit of information about me they can glean * Sponsorship bit are usually there because they have at least some tentative relevance to the content and the people consuming it, without the need to stalk us as we travel around the Internet At least until such time as the video carries like youtube start inserting ads directly into video streams, then I'll reconsider. I don't block ads to block ads: I block adds as a side effect of blocking stalking behaviours, wasted bandwidth from auto-playing video, 3rd party code on otherwise half-reputable sites trying to access my camera & mic, slowing my devices via poorly optimised animations, pop-ups that may interrupt other app use away from the browser, pop-unders too, battery drain from CPU use when mobile, being forced to interact because I can't just look around or scroll past as the ad is over the content, ... If the stalky inserts start to happen then I'll react by using sponsorblock or similar.