3 ms·
I'm really puzzled with the army's enthusiasm for lasers, wouldn't for instance a heat shield coated with a highly reflective material completely neglect its ef
by littlestymaar 5y ago
I'm really puzzled with the army's enthusiasm for lasers, wouldn't for instance a heat shield coated with a highly reflective material completely neglect its effect?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kcb 5y agoIt's not really feasible to put some advanced heat shield on every surface of a missile, plane, or ship.
- littlestymaar 5y agoYou don't need it on “every surface” though, merely on the front.
- ranger207 5y agoNo reflective material is perfectly reflective, and any scratches or soot or whatever will increase the amount of heat transferred from the laser to the missile. Heat shields are more effective, but it's unlikely that missiles can carry enough to resist lasers while still remaining effective, similarly to how missiles could carry armor against CIWS, but then they'd be too heavy.
- dragontamer 5y agoTheory of Combined Arms: All weapons are countered by a kind of armor. All armor is countered by a different kind of weapon. The goal is not to build an uncounterable weapon. The goal is to have a variety of weapons that force contradictory responses. > wouldn't for instance a heat shield coated with a highly reflective material completely neglect its effect? Good job negating the laser. Except the warship also has AI-guided missiles who will lock onto your highly-reflective paint way easier. Combined Arms: by defending yourself against one weapon, you made yourself vulnerable to another. You're not trying to survive against a laser, you're trying to survive against a DDG warship. The DDG has lasers, homing missiles, and guns. Your anti-DDG weapon needs to survive all three of them to be effective.
- littlestymaar 5y agoThat's a good point. Even though my remark was mostly about the fact that there seems[1] to be few modern weapon systems for which there exists such an effective armor. [1] at least from an amateur's point of view
- dragontamer 5y ago* Guided missiles are countered by stealth. You can't "lock onto" a target if its paint absorbs all forms of RADAR / senses. * HEAT rounds are countered by reactive armor. Using an explosion upon impact means that the opponent can "counter-explode", and negate the physical effects of your explosion. * SABOT / Armor Piercing rounds are countered by range. * Big guns (120mm+) are countered by smaller targets spread out over a larger area. Big guns take a longer time to reload and fire, meaning you can easily get surrounded and killed. * Small guns (12.7mm and smaller) are countered by various forms of armor. Sure, they can be fired extremely rapidly and kill many soft / unarmored targets. But a small-gun will never do anything to a tank or larger warship. * Direct fire (both big and small) are countered by trenches and bunkers. It doesn't matter how big your gun is, it won't go through a dug-in dirt position. * Indirect fire beats trenches. You lob your mortar very high into the air and drop them down on the enemy. -------------- All weapons are countered by a strategy and/or technology. Lasers seem like the "combined arms" counterpart to Guided Missiles. The more your paint absorbs RADAR, the worse it will perform against lasers. Big guns vs Small Guns is your Tank + Soldier combined arms. Small guns lose to tanks. Big guns win vs Tanks. Big Guns lose vs soldiers, small guns win vs Soldiers. All weapons have some defense that beats them. Every defense loses to another weapon.
- littlestymaar 5y agoAt some point I imagined you new something about the topic, but given the big list of cliché you've just wrote, it seems that I was wrong. War isn't some kind of rock paper scissors as in RTS games.
- dragontamer 5y ago