2 ms·
What if I wrote a radio app, and someone provided me the URL of CBC's stream. I've never visited their website; how can I possibly be bound by their terms of se
by dangrossman 15y ago
What if I wrote a radio app, and someone provided me the URL of CBC's stream. I've never visited their website; how can I possibly be bound by their terms of service? A contract requires agreement and contractual intent -- can't exist where I haven't even seen the terms. I'm also not creating any copies of their work, so copyright law doesn't come into play. Where's the legal basis in stopping my app?
[I am not the OP, just creating a scenario]
- HannibalLecter 15y agoI would normally nod your love of subversion, but you're off base today. Their website has the terms and conditions displayed on it, so your ignorance of their terms of conditions is not their problem -- it's yours. The streams are owned by CBC and they have the right to decide how someone uses them and they have the right to make sure nobody profits off their use who has no affiliation to CBC. You know what's awesome here is that CBC didn't attempt to claim the money the guy made. That really says something about the kind of people who work at the CBC, especially their legal team. I have nothing but respect for those people.
- cube13 15y agoI think that would be fine. It's the exact same thing as iTunes or WMP.
- voyou 15y ago> I'm also not creating any copies of their work. To listen to the content they are streaming on their website, you need to make a copy of it. Now, you could argue that, by creating a URL which will stream that content to any program that asks for it, they have implicitly given everyone permission to copy it in order to listen to it, but I'm not sure that's legally sound, particularly given that AFAICS, the only way in which they publish that URL is in the context of the specific player on their website. (Now, as a publicly-owned broadcaster, the CBC should be streaming its content in a way that allows anyone - or anyone in Canada, anyway - to access it how they choose; but that's a somewhat separate question.)