8 ms·
> if both coal and nuclear are down, can we say that nuclear replaced coal, or did coal only replace nuclear? IMHO it depends on the purpose of the decrease. I
by fsflover 5y ago
> if both coal and nuclear are down, can we say that nuclear replaced coal, or did coal only replace nuclear?
IMHO it depends on the purpose of the decrease. If it's about green energy, then removing the nuclear while keeping the coal is a wrong choice (see links above), and the remaining coal was chosen to be kept instead of the remaining nuclear. I would call it "coal replaced nuclear". You may have a different opinion on the semantics. It doesn't matter much. What matters is the wrong choice which led to unnecessary CO2 and radiation in the air (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal#Damage_to_human_health https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal#Damage_to_human_health).
> Nuclear is so green, the japanese people will shell out $200B for the cleanup of the mess. So much for that argument.
There is a difference between an anecdote and reliable statistics.