6 ms·
Not charging 30% for ongoing revenue would immediately result in all apps being “free” with an in—app subscription. Like… within months. Why do people not get
by jiggawatts 5y ago
Not charging 30% for ongoing revenue would immediately result in all apps being “free” with an in—app subscription.
Like… within months.
Why do people not get this?
Apple wants their cut. This is the only way for them to get any cut at all. It’s either this rule or $0 revenue.
- bitexploder 5y agoNo possible percentages in between 0 and 30%?
- jiggawatts 5y agoIt's the industry standard. Most similar marketplaces (e.g.: Steam store, etc...) charge 30%.
- bwilli123 5y agoIt's reasonable to assume that Apple chose 30% because that was the prevailing standard in the physical retail world. That markup has been competed away in some circumstances (eg Costco) but otherwise still holds generally (Walmart 32%) It reflects unavoidable costs to all retailers, like local rents, staffing, transport etc Given that tech does not have a retail's fixed costs why has that markup not been competed away to establish a markup based on tech's unavoidable fixed costs?
- jiggawatts 5y agoWhat is your argument here? That Apple's services cost literally nothing to provide? Apple provides developers access to an enormous marketplace that they run. A marketplace with hundreds of millions of "high value" customers pre-configured for payments. All sorts of related services are included, such as fraud detection, currency conversion, etc... What do you think Apple does? Just skim 30% off the top without doing anything else? Seriously, some people live in this fantasy world where all products should be worth 100% of their raw material cost, and services should cost only what the showroom rent+aircon costs to provide.
- heavyset_go 5y agoApple's profit margin on the App Store was ~80% in 2019[1]. In a healthy market, competition would lead to increased efficiencies and more savings for consumers that would cut into those margins. Instead the market has stagnated because competition was forbidden, and one company profits handsomely from it. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-05-01/apple-s-app-store-had-78-profit-margin-in-2019-testimony-shows https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-05-01/apple-s-a...
- colinmhayes 5y agosteam charges 20-25%
- tomxor 5y ago> Apple wants their cut. This is the only way for them to get any cut at all. It’s either this rule or $0 revenue. Why do they deserve a cut? Uber and Lyft, deliver a material service, Apple have not contributed to that in any way beyond existing as a general purpose computer manufacturer. Take an alternative, food delivery service, you pay a monthly subscription for a set selection of fruit and veg delivered every week. The cost is made up of food cost and delivery cost... You could sign up through a website, or you could sign up through an app on Apple's app store, in the later case the only option would be to increase the price by 30%, because there is no where near 30% profit left over. Not convinced? Ok lets go to an extreme, what about a mortgage monthly repayment app, that's essentially a subscription to your home right? Do you think Apple deserve to have almost 30% of the value of your house for the privilege of letting you use an app to pay? Does their App store really deliver that much value? Before, it was sort of justifiable when people were trying their get rich quick schemes with flappy bird clones... because the argument from the other side was a weak "but that's my get rich quick scheme", Apple's platform and what they shove in front of users faces made a real difference to the almost pure profit of those Apps, the apps simply would not be popular without Apple... but as soon as we start talking about apps that deliver material services and other significant value it makes no sense to argue that Apple deserve even 1 penny. Apple have gone completely fucking mental with their own greed, they think they deserve a slice of the entire world.
- jiggawatts 5y ago> Why do they deserve a cut? I don't know if you're trolling or not... but are you seriously unaware of the value they're providing? Is this some kind of mystery to many people? In the PC/Linux space -- where traditionally no online marketplace existed with wide reach -- if you want to sell your software you have to pull yourself up by your own bootstraps: 1. Create a website. 2. Market your software. Nobody will see it. Spend more money on more marketing, and then maybe -- just maybe -- you might reach 1-10% of your potential market. 3. Sign up with a credit card payment processor. Find out that people will navigate all the way to your store page, see the CC entry form, and click cancel. A lot of people. Like... 50%. 4. Discover that you're treated like the dirt stuck to the bottom of the payment processor's shoes, and they charge a lot of overhead too. Especially for small transcations. You have no hope, ever, of selling 1 million copies of your small app for $1 and make anywhere near a million dollars. 5. Get hacked because you can't afford a full security team to babysit your online store 24/7. 6. Discover that you're on the second page of Google's search results for your exact product name because of competitor's SEO. 7. And so on. And on, and on... Apple's 30% cut is cheap. It's notably less than doing it yourself at a small scale, under one million dollars or so. They instantly provide you with hundreds of millions of potential customers, free marketing and exposure, frictionless payment processing that goes down to the single-dollar range efficiently, secure systems for all of that, and more. Everybody in the mobile app industry knows that while there are more Android devices out there, the profit is in the Apple ecosystem. An ecosystem Apple created at enormous expense. An ecosystem that has devices that are mostly kept up-to-date (by Apple! For 6+ years! At huge expense!), massively reducing development and test effort. Notably, unlike the Android platform which is a shit-show of bargain basement garbage with either zero vendor support, or next to zero. An ecosystem where customers feel safe because of the security guarantees provided by Apple! Confident customers spend more. A lot more. The Android marketplace is like 30% malware at this point, for comparison. Customers don't feel safe spending their money there. I know I don't. I could go on like this for pages and pages, but I hope you get the point. You're getting the end-result of the main product of the world's biggest company. If you think this is worthless, literally without value, then you're probably one of those people that also think that they could reproduce the Uber app over a weekend...